You're not a wedding band ... and I can't imagine why you think you can be for this one gig. Do your cousin a favor and just bow out. It takes a lot more than a set list to be a good wedding band or DJ.
Please don't take my post as a criticism of your band or skill as musicians. A lot will depend on what your cousin expects from your band. Does he want to save a few bucks over the DJ thinking your band will essentially be a live juke box. If so, can you guys cover a wide variety of musical styles. Can you play, or even want to play, YMCA, Celebration, or Brick House, which seem to be wedding staples. How about newer tunes in the pop, r&b, and dance genres? Can your lead singer cover those tunes as well?
I could be very wrong (I often am), but in my gut I see this as a potential red flag in terms of band chemistry. A lot of work to get "wedding ready" -- you gotta have everyone committed and bought in. One guy flakes out and you just boned your cousin.
Good luck with whatever choice you make.
Band chemistry I'm not worried about - by "not too long" and "not close" I meant we haven't been gigging geographically close to my cousin, so there hasn't been much opportunity for him to have seen us, ergo I approached him rather than vice versa. The members of the band are very committed and play very well together.
A GOOD DJ doesn't just stand there with his hat on sideways saying, "Yo Dawg." A good DJ is a master of ceremonies and knows all of the little things involved in helping to make the wedding a success, i.e. The first dance, dance with the father, cutting the cake, calling a line dance. A really good DJ can run the show and make it enjoyable for everyone. My nephew got married last year and the DJ was absolutely fantastic and well worth $1500. It doesn't seem like the OPs band can do any of that.
Also, a crappy band can ruin a wedding.
This (and some of the other quotes I grabbed) are getting at what I'm trying to learn - being told "you're not a wedding band, don't bother" falls in the not-very-helpful column. What I'm trying to find out is where the differences are so that I can figure out how well positioned we are to pull off the gig successfully and whether any adjustments we need to make will be worth it.
Varieties of musical styles - check. We've got stuff from 70s classic rock to new country to Katy Perry. We can be versatile. I do have doubts about how prepared we could be to pull off any random on-the-spot request, but anything we're asked to prepare we can prepare.
Renting tuxes - check. Easy enough to do.
MC the event - this would be something I would need to talk to my cousin about; I don't know if the quote from the DJ was for MC'ing as well as running music, it may well have been. Wouldn't be a deal-breaker for me if we were expected to do it.
What else? Keep it coming.
