• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bass for each style

View attachment 4165962


OP: 'looking the part' is more important in some genres than others. IME: playing/sounding the part is what musicians do --- in any genre. so any competent electric bass + any competent player = any style. no matter what the bass --- or the player --- looks like!


"OK, 'the girl from ipanema', here we go, 1...2...3...4..."
View attachment 4165970

i don't think an original band trying to do something new will do a cover ... especially of a song like that ... kind of go against what you claim
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRA
Any bass for anything, but I do have preferences.

Jazz/latin jazz: DB
R&B/soul/funk: J or ray
Latin: fretless BG (lotta guys play fretted 5 or 6 string BG for modern salsa, I just prefer fretless)
Rock: P or L-2500
Anything I gotta read: 5- or 6-string

this ^

For me it's:

Upright - jazz & Americana
Fender P w flats - blues, classic rock, jazz
Lakland J5 - funk, rock, covers, Latin
Kala U Bass - couch, grab & go, calypso, Bach cello suites
 
i don't think an original band trying to do something new will do a cover ... especially of a song like that ... kind of go against what you claim
:wideyed:

it was my meager attempt at using humor to make a point. :laugh: i realize that my sense of humor is subject to the critical thinking of others, which is beyond my control, so i'm sorry about any confusion, or offense taken. mostly. :D

of course, i'm hoping that you agree with the point i was making: any ax for any music. but if you don't = it's OK! ;)
 
Last edited:
Tapes, Flats, and Rounds.
Ebony, Maple, and Rosewood.
PJ, P, J.
Fretless, Vintage Frets, Medium Jumbo Frets.
Passive - Active.
Covers enough ground for me.
20210204_113455.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: RONTERGO and Bexuga
:wideyed:

it was my meager attempt at using humor to make a point. :laugh: i realize that my sense of humor is subject to the critical thinking of others, which is beyond my control, so i'm sorry about any confusion, or offense taken. mostly. :D

of course, i'm hoping that you agree with the point i was making: any ax for any music. but if you don't = it's OK! ;)
Hahaha I see now! Its all good
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRA
But seriously even though I regularly play Several basses with rounds and flats I'd bring a fretted and fretless and assume I can cover anything with one or the other. And honestly if I had to play any set with just a fretless or a P with flats or a Ray with rounds nobody would know but me and maybe the guitarist and mostly that would be switching from blue to black or red or natural.
It's all in our heads, y'all. But you should still have more than 1 because the fun multiplies.
 
Everybody has their own opinion, so this conservation will always continue ad nauseum, with no clear consensus. Really, any bass is good for any style, in the right hands, with proper EQ'ing, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bexuga
Hi guys, just looking to soak up on your expertise: What would you say is the appropriate bass for each music style?
Like P bass for rock (and pretty much anything), J for jazz, funk and reggae, Ibañez or Dean for metal...

Easy. Any bass for any style.

No reason to overthink it.

Get the bass you like best and play what you want.

There are nobby thingies on the amp to tweek the tone.
 
I'm guessing you're young, and weren't part of the music scene before 1980.

You might be suprised that the British invasion guys (Beatles, Rolling Stones, etc.) made their music without Fender basses (they couldn't afford them). Add in Chris Squire (70's on a Rick - Rick sold a LOT of 4001's in the 70's), Geddy (he didn't play Fenders until well AFTER 1980), Jack Bruce (Gibsons) and a few others (Fender didn't sell many basses in the later 1970's - they were poorly built and didn't have points on them), and...I think you'd be surprised how much music was made before 1980 on non-Fender basses.

Oh, and the 1980's were about as Fender free as any decade. People wanted pointy basses and Spandex, and Fender didn't sell either.

Well, sorry to disappoint you, but at age 68, having grown up in the 50s-60s well as being a pro musician there after, when you heard an electric bass back then, more than likely it was a Fender bass. As for what was used in England in your example was driven by what was available, as well as the steep duties applied imported instruments.

I'm not exactly sure where you got the stats to support that Fender didn't sell many basses in the later 70's, I sure didn't see that many less. I did see other options more often however, in an increasing percentage that has continued to this day.
 
P bass can do pretty much everything, but variety is the spice of life! I've got a pbass, fretless tele bass, fretless jazz style bass, T-20 w/rounds, and a club bass. They're all a little different in application, some better for harder music, some for softer, some more distinctive, others rather nondescript. They all get played.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bexuga