• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Bassist with most UNIQUE tone

Mud Flaps said:
You can't say that Marcus Miller, Jaco Pastorius, and Stanley Clarke have a unique tone because their tones are textbook, everyone tries to copy it. Thus, it is no longer unique tone, it is now only original and classic.

My votes:

Les Claypool - That rubbery sound. Also very original in the way he equalizes with the mid turned all the way up.

John Myung - Very strange crunchy sound because he uses injection boxes rather than amplifiers.

(Recent) Stanley Clarke- He's been using wierd effects lately. That's certainly one way to get an original tone.

Stu Hamm - His bass and the open slap lines give him a pretty wierd sound.


Yes I (we) can say because the key word is _you wrote it yourself_ everyone TRIES to copy it. but cannot SUCCEED which makes them still unique.Because I think unique tone not only relates to the instrument or the eq ,but nuch more to the players hands as well ..So My vote goes for 4 people I know.Marcus Miller , Mark King , Steve Harris and ...Fieldy(though I hate his tone )..As I can recognise them from the very first seconds of a song that I ve never heard before.

IMHO les claypool doesnt have a unique tone as I dont find him a very unique player .Just a very strong expressionist but sloppy player IMO
 
Woodchuck said:
Excellent! Slide bass at its finest! I was on stage the night he died in Italy. After I heard about it, my lead singer whispered to me, "Your tears are showing." I didn't cry, but I was glassy eyed.


It's alright... you can admit you :bawl: ed ;)



Mark Sandman was a helluva bassist. basstriaxis was talking about starting a no guitar band trend (as opposed to no bass)... See Morphine. :bassist:
 
I have decided to not look at a single post before me, so this is all me baby!

Flea- the earlier MM stuff.

Marcus Miller- One of the best and most unique sounding slap tones to my ears.

Les Claypool- It is the CT that does it i suppose- although he gets equally funky tone out of his jazz.

Victor Wooten- Great unique finger and slapping tone. PErhaps it has to do with his technique?

Fieldy- Clankity Clank- pretty unique i guess.

Ryan Martine- Great Fretless mwah on those Warwicks. Don't know if i would call it unique, but he definately has his own sound.

Jeff Berlin- Man, he has one of the sweetest fingerstyle tones IMO.

Jaco- I am suer he has been brought up a billion times in this thread.

Geddy Lee- UNMISTAKABLE tone...

John Paul Jones- that 8 string makes his tone very unique.

Stanley Clarke- Maybe it is just the alembic, but his tone is pretty unique sounding.

Stu Hamm- BIG slap sound that is easily picked up and identified as his own.

Mark King- Same can be said about him.

(edit) Chrish Squire- Can't believe I forgot him! Great unique crunchy picked-Ric tone that we all know and love

Mike Dirnt- Don't know if i spelled his name right, but he has a nice throaty treb sound that I really dig.

That about does it i suppose (I know I will think of some more later). IT was hard to think about this, because there are so many great bassists (Nathan East, Steve Bailey, John Myung, Doug Wimbish, Pino...)- but not all of them have a really distinct tone. Not to say any of them have bad tone, they just dont stick out over anyone else.
 
well i didnt see it ...maybe i didnt look good enough but my vote goes jason newsted. its so great it fits in great...or did with metallica...havent heard much of him lately. my fav bass player also. vote 2....yes probably mr.clifford burton....very...pongy(???) would be the word id use
 
stanger503 said:
well i didnt see it ...maybe i didnt look good enough but my vote goes jason newsted. its so great it fits in great...or did with metallica...havent heard much of him lately. my fav bass player also. vote 2....yes probably mr.clifford burton....very...pongy(???) would be the word id use


I dunno.... I don't think I could pull Jason's tone out if you laid it in front of me. Then again, I dont really listen to Metallica.