• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Best flats for a P poll

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 165050
  • Start date Start date

Best flatwounds on a Precision

  • TI Jazz Flats

    Votes: 171 23.5%
  • La Bella LTF

    Votes: 64 8.8%
  • Dunlop flatwound

    Votes: 29 4.0%
  • DR Legend

    Votes: 13 1.8%
  • D'Addario Chrome

    Votes: 99 13.6%
  • Roto 77

    Votes: 34 4.7%
  • Ernie Ball flatwound

    Votes: 37 5.1%
  • La Bella DTF

    Votes: 148 20.3%
  • GHS Precision

    Votes: 61 8.4%
  • Fender flatwound

    Votes: 53 7.3%
  • Gibson flatwound

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • Optima Flats

    Votes: 2 0.3%
  • Pyramid Gold

    Votes: 7 1.0%
  • Sadowsky

    Votes: 9 1.2%

  • Total voters
    729
My vote still is set on the labellas for now but i'm messing around with a set of GHS regular and a set of light on two different basses and i have to say that for about half the price of the labellas i like them a lot... might have to try a light set of labellas to compare ( currently have a set of 760M on my fender p ) but one of those set is gonna stay on that's for sure
 
  • Like
Reactions: R&B
I'd be interested to hear how the low B works out
The low B in the new set of TI flats works great on my Jazz V. The notes are clear and sustained, with minimal fluctuation in pitch, which is sometimes a problem with B strings.

TI makes only one gauge for each string, and their B string is .136 -- which is even chunkier than the B string in the set of Ernie Ball Slinky flats that this set is replacing (which was .135). Yet the TI set has less tension than the Ernie Ball set, which I worried would lead to a floppy sort of B string response, but it's actually less floppy than the Ernie Ball was -- which maybe helps explain the more consistent pitch response. And because of the lower tension, the truss rod can be (needs to be) loosened.

Also, in comparison with the Ernie Ball set, the entire TI set is smoother to the touch, and this is most noticeable on the B string itself, just because it's so big.

Note: these strings are brand new, so YMMV after breaking them in.
 
I reached out to Thomastik-Infeld for the manufacturer's stance on stringing: "Thank you for your interest in our products. Please note, the strings in the set JF344 where designed for a standard bridge, however musicians often do stringing them also through the body.
I hope this helps."
 
  • Like
Reactions: rzero
Out of the list I've only played Roto 77, La Bella Deep Talkin' Flats, Fender, TI Jazz, and Chromes. Chromes on a P did nothing for me--way too zingy and mid-forward. TI Jazz lost the zing but still had too much midrange for my taste, not worth their expense. Bought a bass with Fender flats on it which sounded OK.

My winners are LaBella DTF's are Roto 77's, the former if I want a more old-school sound, the latter for a more lively feel and a more modern/versatile overall sound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rzero
So. Many. Opinions! And here's yet another...

You'll find absolutely no love whatsoever in my house for any LaBella or TI strings. The former are pure sonic mud (I've tried DTF and LTF, *and* a set of their SS rounds. Barf!), the latter are like little elastic bands, and I just cannot take them seriously. I realize these are by far the two most popular things among the hive mind here, but that's been my experience. My P-Bass is something of a "treble eater" though, and so I find it gets a more balanced tone with slightly brighter strings.

My favourite for a while was the GHS Precision flats, but after using stainless steels on that P for many a year, I've got some Roto 77 flats on it now. These are great (for flats)! This is my first experience with them, but no problems whatsoever with balanced output that others have mentioned here. They are flats, so it's definitely a warm, old school thump, but there's a little presence and zing to them which I rather enjoy. I only use this bass now for old school soul/RnB gigs, so it doesn't need to do anything but be thumpy; hence my return to flats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: billgwx and Brkls
About the 760FL you mean ?
To me they sound a little fatter then the 760m. I think high tension strings might have more mids or are more balanced then light strings... but at the price of bottom sometimes. Not saying the 760m don't have booty but the 760fl seem to have a tad more or it is rounder but with the same kind of mids. They almost sound saturated to me specially when you play near the 12 fret. You get that deep yet rich sound that reminds me McCartney ( i have them paired with a Ori62 Pickup ) The tension is also way more comfortable. The E string on the 760FL is very close in feel ( size wise ) to the A string of the 760M. So yeah HUGE HUGE difference. The feel of the material is super smooth ( like on all the labellas i'm guessing ). Very noticeable when you do slides. String noise is at a minimum. And they just vibrate more then the 760m so you can feel it when you're playing. Less fatiguing and more vibe.
 
About the 760FL you mean ?
To me they sound a little fatter then the 760m. I think high tension strings might have more mids or are more balanced then light strings... but at the price of bottom sometimes. Not saying the 760m don't have booty but the 760fl seem to have a tad more or it is rounder but with the same kind of mids. They almost sound saturated to me specially when you play near the 12 fret. You get that deep yet rich sound that reminds me McCartney ( i have them paired with a Ori62 Pickup ) The tension is also way more comfortable. The E string on the 760FL is very close in feel ( size wise ) to the A string of the 760M. So yeah HUGE HUGE difference. The feel of the material is super smooth ( like on all the labellas i'm guessing ). Very noticeable when you do slides. String noise is at a minimum. And they just vibrate more then the 760m so you can feel it when you're playing. Less fatiguing and more vibe.

760FL is a great set of strings. I love 'em!

- Steve
 
About the 760FL you mean ?
To me they sound a little fatter then the 760m. I think high tension strings might have more mids or are more balanced then light strings... but at the price of bottom sometimes. Not saying the 760m don't have booty but the 760fl seem to have a tad more or it is rounder but with the same kind of mids. They almost sound saturated to me specially when you play near the 12 fret. You get that deep yet rich sound that reminds me McCartney ( i have them paired with a Ori62 Pickup ) The tension is also way more comfortable. The E string on the 760FL is very close in feel ( size wise ) to the A string of the 760M. So yeah HUGE HUGE difference. The feel of the material is super smooth ( like on all the labellas i'm guessing ). Very noticeable when you do slides. String noise is at a minimum. And they just vibrate more then the 760m so you can feel it when you're playing. Less fatiguing and more vibe.
Probably related to how short scale basses sound fatter. It's true on guitars as well. Lighter gauge strings resonate more and to some they sound fatter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brkls
I am a bit surprised to see TI Jazz Flats as the top choice. I knew they had a lot of diehard fans, but holy cow, more than LaBella? They're some very polarizing strings IMHO. I don't like the way they feel like they're rolling under my fingers, and even though I hear a lot of bassists sound great with them, I couldn't get them to sound like anything but rounds without as much finger noise. But the results speak for themselves.
 
I am a bit surprised to see TI Jazz Flats as the top choice. I knew they had a lot of diehard fans, but holy cow, more than LaBella? They're some very polarizing strings IMHO. I don't like the way they feel like they're rolling under my fingers, and even though I hear a lot of bassists sound great with them, I couldn't get them to sound like anything but rounds without as much finger noise. But the results speak for themselves.

I prefer low tension flats myself... TIJFs and LTFs are my favourite for feel. Currently have a set of standard gauge DTFs on one bass but finding them very stiff and switching to light.