• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Best strings for classic blues?

I know literally nothing about how different strings might produce different sounds? Or do I get what I pay for when I buy the $50 strings v. the $20 ones? Are some strings better for slap than others? (Yes, I've been dabbling, aka practicing for hours on end just to decode this wacky skill set.)

I'm heading into our big guitar center today and don't want to appear to be the total nube that I am. Give me some good buzz words and intelligent questions to ask.

Thank you! I love you! You are literally the best!
 
I know literally nothing about how different strings might produce different sounds? Or do I get what I pay for when I buy the $50 strings v. the $20 ones? Are some strings better for slap than others? (Yes, I've been dabbling, aka practicing for hours on end just to decode this wacky skill set.)

I'm heading into our big guitar center today and don't want to appear to be the total nube that I am. Give me some good buzz words and intelligent questions to ask.

Thank you! I love you! You are literally the best!
Re the different prices, what Bongo said above. Many players can get by just fine with a 10-buck string set, even, if their skin chemistry agrees with it (sometimes, a product just doesn't last on you - it happens). Some sets cost fifty bucks because they're imported (but the tone makes it worth it for you), some are coated, some are more time/component/labour-intensive.

Re differences, especially in tone - in a nutshell:
  • roundwounds (the undisputed standard for at least four decades) are less expensive, as a tendency less durable, but wider-range (more sustain, more mids and highs). Their treble response sometimes needs to be reined in, by cutting highs at the amp, or simply with the tone knob at the bass. They're rougher to the touch, and finger-noisier (all the fretting hand against string squeaks get amplified, unless you EQ them out, as said). Of these, the clear majority are nickel-plated steel (NPS for brevity); compared to them, stainless steel are more trebly, whereas pure nickel wound strings (Fender 7150; GHS Balanced Nickel; Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Rounds) are warmer-sounding, and less common;
  • example of coated rounds are the Elixir brand, DR colored strings, D'Addario XT, Ibanez. They sound like rounds, essentially (with a little less zing and finger noise), but last longer;
  • modified rounds (pressurewounds, as made by GHS; groundwounds like D'Addario Half Rounds and GHS Brite Flats) are smoother to the touch than pure rounds, less squeaky, less trebly, still very versatile;
  • nylon tapewounds have subdued highs, but can be very lively (some of the sets that LaBella makes are transparent in appearance, and called White Nylon, and the brightest out there in terms of tone, too; the rest, including some others by the same company, are black in colour, and darker in tone, with Fender and D'Addario being still classifiable as "bright" to an extent, and Rotosound Tru Bass 88 as "thumpy". Tapes potentially last a long time;
  • flatwounds also last years, as long as you still like their tone by then, and come in many flavours. Most start out a little clangy (for most of them this goes away with some breaking-in) but the balance of bass-to-mid/treble varies:
- Ernie Ball Slinky Flatwounds (colloquially "Cobalt Flats") are bright, and comparable to worn-in roundwounds; D'Addario Chromes are also pretty bright (in time, again depending on hand chemistry, they get darker);
- Rotosound Jazz Bass 77, Fender 9050, Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Flats (often referred to as "TI flats") are different from one another but make up a loose category of midrangy flats;
- Ernie Ball steel flatwounds (aka "Group" flats), Dunlop flats, Sadowsky flats, Optima flats are often described as in-between the brightest and the darkest bunch (there may be crosstalk or differences in attribution within this category and the previous);
- La Bella Deep Talkin' Flats, DR Legend, GHS Precision, Pyramid Gold (and others) fall in the thumpy, traditional (they were an important component of the classic electric bass guitar tones of the '60s), dark camp.

Generally speaking, flats slot very well in band mixes, but they don't lend themselves to "cutting through" per se, and may sometimes have trouble with note definition unless some care is taken in EQing them (mid boost, bass cut).
___

For classic blues with some slap thrown in (and some judicious use of the tone knob), I'd consider
- pure nickel roundwounds;
- pressurewounds or groundwounds;
- black nylon tapewounds;
- bright flatwounds
as outlined above. Another's mileage/take may vary.
 
Last edited:
Depending on what you mean by classic. For blues rock styles I’d strongly recommend your current favorite strings but for older standards I’d play what I’m used to playing. Round or flat, whatever you already prefer.

Killing Floor knows a thing or two about the best strings for blues.
 
I know literally nothing about how different strings might produce different sounds? Or do I get what I pay for when I buy the $50 strings v. the $20 ones? Are some strings better for slap than others? (Yes, I've been dabbling, aka practicing for hours on end just to decode this wacky skill set.)

I've learned 95% of what I know about bass strings here on TalkBass. I literally read every post in every thread that came up in the "Strings" section for the first year. That would be one sure way to learn a lot about bass strings.
 
I'm an old, retired, guy who started on double bass and has been playing electric bass since '68. I played roundwounds for the first 3 decades, but the finger and fret noise really began to irritate my tinnitus, so I began trying various flats around the turn of the century. I finally settled on Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Flats, which I now have on almost all of my electric basses.

Some decry their cost and flexibility. The cost is definitely higher than many other strings, but on the basis of cost-per-year they're affordable for someone like me who changes strings once every 10 or 20 years. I have come to love their [relative] flexibility because, especially on my fretless basses, they allow so much more nuance and expression than "stiff" strings.

No matter what else you do, protect your hearing!!

Good luck in your quest! :)
 
I know literally nothing about how different strings might produce different sounds? Or do I get what I pay for when I buy the $50 strings v. the $20 ones? Are some strings better for slap than others? (Yes, I've been dabbling, aka practicing for hours on end just to decode this wacky skill set.)

I'm heading into our big guitar center today and don't want to appear to be the total nube that I am. Give me some good buzz words and intelligent questions to ask.
The juxtaposition of "some strings better for slap than others" with the title "Best strings for classic blues?" is a tad confusing. Most classic blues players don't slap, at least when they're playing classic blues.

That said, it's been my experience that good strings sound good no matter what style of music I'm playing. For your purposes, perhaps the better question might be what gage (thickness) of string you want. If you don't know, I'd recommend something medium or medium light -- so 40-100 or 45-105. If you don't know what that means, ask the guy at the music store to show you the difference.

Two other things to consider is how do you like your tone? and how do you want your strings to feel? Some roundwounds can feel a little sharp, and some flatwounds can feel a little grippy. If neither of those will work for you, there are things like half-rounds and ground-wounds, which are supposed to retain some of the zing of roundwounds but be easier on the fingers. Again, ask the guy at the store to show you examples. (FYI, I use mostly coated roundwounds from DR.)

By the way, there's nothing wrong with being a noob. Everyone starts out as a noob. We've all been there. Being a noob can be great sometimes, because you can ask anything about anything. When you get to a certain point, you might get a little embarrassed about not knowing something you think you should already know. Now? Ask away.
 
Maybe out of my depth compared to some of the responses so far, but have this to share:

Listen to where the mids-character (peak/scoop, timbre, harmonic content) of your strings land in relation to the vocals. For blues-rock I'd want to saturate the mix with warm, resonant tone, giving a platform to the guitars. For bluesy-blues - subdued and vocally nuanced - I'd want to support low down deep but otherwise get out of the way of the singer(s).

Swapped strings in rapid succession on a jazz bass last night... DR Pure Blues on it for a year, which sound very expressive and have easy tension. The LaBella LTFs I was eager to try were bland on this bass. The NYXLs would have been nicer in a lighter gauge and may have been the most mix-friendly. DR NLRs lacked color. Ordering more EB Flats soon, but already have those on two other instruments.

Staying with the DR PB because they've been the best match so far to the "voice" of this bass, even though I'm not sure yet in which musical context that voice fits best.

If you want to look smart buying strings in your local GC... don't ask a sales associate's opinion on strings :laugh:
Just make sure you get the right scale length and string count.
 
Last edited:
Re the different prices, what Bongo said above. Many players can get by just fine with a 10-buck string set, even, if their skin chemistry agrees with it (sometimes, a product just doesn't last on you - it happens). Some sets cost fifty bucks because they're imported (but the tone makes it worth it for you), some are coated, some are more time/component/labour-intensive.

Re differences, especially in tone - in a nutshell:
  • roundwounds (the undisputed standard for at least four decades) are less expensive, as a tendency less durable, but wider-range (more sustain, more mids and highs). Their treble response sometimes needs to be reined in, by cutting highs at the amp, or simply with the tone knob at the bass. They're rougher to the touch, and finger-noisier (all the fretting hand against string squeaks get amplified, unless you EQ them out, as said). Of these, the clear majority are nickel-plated steel (NPS for brevity); compared to them, stainless steel are more trebly, whereas pure nickel wound strings (Fender 7150; GHS Balanced Nickel; Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Rounds) are warmer-sounding, and less common;
  • example of coated rounds are the Elixir brand, DR colored strings, D'Addario XT, Ibanez. They sound like rounds, essentially (with a little less zing and finger noise), but last longer;
  • modified rounds (pressurewounds, as made by GHS; groundwounds like D'Addario Half Rounds and GHS Brite Flats) are smoother to the touch than pure rounds, less squeaky, less trebly, still very versatile;
  • nylon tapewounds have subdued highs, but can be very lively (some of the sets that LaBella makes are transparent in appearance, and called White Nylon, and the brightest out there in terms of tone, too; the rest, including some others by the same company, are black in colour, and darker in tone, with Fender and D'Addario being still classifiable as "bright" to an extent, and Rotosound Tru Bass 88 as "thumpy". Tapes potentially last a long time;
  • flatwounds also last years, as long as you still like their tone by then, and come in many flavours. Most start out a little clangy (for most of them this goes away with some breaking-in) but the balance of bass-to-mid/treble varies:
- Ernie Ball Slinky Flatwounds (colloquially "Cobalt Flats") are bright, and comparable to worn-in roundwounds; D'Addario Chromes are also pretty bright (in time, again depending on hand chemistry, they get darker);
- Rotosound Jazz Bass 77, Fender 9050, Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Flats (often referred to as "TI flats") are different from one another but make up a loose category of midrangy flats;
- Ernie Ball steel flatwounds (aka "Group" flats), Dunlop flats, Sadowsky flats, Optima flats are often described as in-between the brightest and the darkest bunch (there may be crosstalk or differences in attribution within this category and the previous);
- La Bella Deep Talkin' Flats, DR Legend, GHS Precision, Pyramid Gold (and others) fall in the thumpy, traditional (they were an important component of the classic electric bass guitar tones of the '60s), dark camp.
just fine.
Generally speaking, flats slot very well in band mixes, but they don't lend themselves to "cutting through" per se, and may sometimes have trouble with note definition unless some care is taken in EQing them (mid boost, bass cut).
___

For classic blues with some slap thrown in (and some judicious use of the tone knob), I'd conside r
- pure nickel roundwounds;
- pressurewounds or groundwounds;
- black nylon tapewounds;
- bright flatwounds
as outlined above. Another's mileage/take may vary.
^THIS^ pretty much covers it, IMO. But, since I've played flat wounds almost exclusively for... well, a long, long time? My inclination is to say "Flats. Definitely flats". And, since I do play Blues - along with pre-mid '70s Rock; Rockabilly; pre- mid '60s C&W; and a little R&B/Motown occasionally - I think I'd recommend a set of Fender 9050Ls. Not nearly as expensive as the TIJFs; not nearly as stiff/high tension as the Roto 77LDs; and more likely to be found in a decent sized music store (although the Roto's are likely to be there, too). Depending on your bass - and your amp - you can make the Fenders thump just fine. And, while they're not ideal for slapping, they'll get the job done if you do your part. I currently have them on 3 of my basses; An Eastwood Magnum; a Danelectro DC59 Pro; and a G&L Tom Hamilton Signature ASAT Bass. And, while the Dano is not a really thumpy bass wearing the 9050Ls, the G&L ASAT can thump your fillings loose with them. If that's what you want. Or, they can be almost as bright as the D' Addario Chromes that the G&L used to wear. The Fenders are a very good place to start from, if you decide you want to play flats...:cool:
 
^THIS^ pretty much covers it, IMO. But, since I've played flat wounds almost exclusively for... well, a long, long time? My inclination is to say "Flats. Definitely flats". And, since I do play Blues - along with pre-mid '70s Rock; Rockabilly; pre- mid '60s C&W; and a little R&B/Motown occasionally - I think I'd recommend a set of Fender 9050Ls. Not nearly as expensive as the TIJFs; not nearly as stiff/high tension as the Roto 77LDs; and more likely to be found in a decent sized music store (although the Roto's are likely to be there, too). Depending on your bass - and your amp - you can make the Fenders thump just fine. And, while they're not ideal for slapping, they'll get the job done if you do your part. I currently have them on 3 of my basses; An Eastwood Magnum; a Danelectro DC59 Pro; and a G&L Tom Hamilton Signature ASAT Bass. And, while the Dano is not a really thumpy bass wearing the 9050Ls, the G&L ASAT can thump your fillings loose with them. If that's what you want. Or, they can be almost as bright as the D' Addario Chromes that the G&L used to wear. The Fenders are a very good place to start from, if you decide you want to play flats...:cool:
Agreed 100%.

And welcome back!
 
Thanks. I posted here, and a couple of other places on the 4th, just to see if I was really allowed back. Since it seems that I am, I plan to be very circumspect, terse, and to the point in the future. And, I'll be keeping anything that smells, however faintly, of an opinion strictly to myself. So, say goodbye to the old GIBrat...:bag: