• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Capacitors and Tone

The thing with this guy is that whatever he does he does it to the absolute max, hence this system, which could generate enough sound pressure to blow out his floor-to-ceiling plate glass windows if he leans on the volume too much. I just wish that he could somehow learn to enjoy music for it's own sake: for it's musicality rather than it's ability to demonstrate his system. I can't tell how good it actually is, there is no way for me to load anything that I like or am familiar with (unless I happen to be carrying my CD or DVD collection around with me).
 
That part has me confused too. From my current (very limited) understanding an audio taper pot has 10% change at half rotation while a linear pot has 50% change at half rotation. Would not a linear pot give a more effective range of tonal variation? Or am I missing something there?
That's how the taper works but not how our ears work. Our ears don't hear in a linear fashion, so the audio taper was designed to dupe us into thinking we're hearing a linear control. Linear taper, meanwhile, is actually linear, but we don't hear it as such.

If you use a linear taper for tone, you won't hear the effect until the last bit of the rotation, which bunches the entire sweep into a narrow range, giving you less control (it becomes almost like a switch). So with a linear taper pot, most of the rotation goes to waste, whereas with an audio taper pot, you'll hear the effect of the rotation evenly across the pot.

On the other hand, with volume pots, the bunching effect can actually be desirable because it allows one to turn back the volume a fair bit before one hears any/much volume reduction. Meanwhile, series resistance is being introduced; in the case of a two-pickup bass, this helps isolate the pickups from one another, allowing for finer control over the pickup blend.

There are quite a few threads devoted to linear vs. audio taper for volume controls, but I can't imagine anyone preferring a linear taper for a tone pot. (Of course, I can also imagine someone now responding that they do. But take no heed--that person is wrong. :eyebrow:)
 
That's how the taper works but not how our ears work.
Thank you for that explanation fermata, I wondered if it was related to how our ears work!

On a slightly different but related note, I just purchased a 250K pot that the seller says has a 'vintage' taper, where there is a 30% change at half rotation. I thought I was getting a regular linear taper. What would this pot be better suited for? Tone or Volume?

Thanks again!
 
I have a comment and question pls!

I recently bought a Reverend mercalli 5 string bass (played bass most of my 68 y o life) but I can’t seem to get the nice mid honk that I like from the big bridge pickup,
My unlearned question: how can I get more mids out of this bass pls? New capacitor? Change the electronics for a NTMB3 or sone other pre?

Thank you guys n gals!
 
I have a comment and question pls!

I recently bought a Reverend mercalli 5 string bass (played bass most of my 68 y o life) but I can’t seem to get the nice mid honk that I like from the big bridge pickup,
My unlearned question: how can I get more mids out of this bass pls? New capacitor? Change the electronics for a NTMB3 or sone other pre?

Thank you guys n gals!
Some pickups and their positioning might not be capable to produce the tone you are looking for. Perhaps you need an equalizer pedal. The tone capacitor in the passive setup does very little. Of course it is possible to put together a filter that can make things better for you but, using a good eq, should be more helpful. Unfortunately, I have not used an eq pedals and have nothing to recommend. Parametric EQ would be ultimately more capable, but it is very difficult to make sense of if you are not familiar with how to use one. Maybe there is an eq pedals which can be controlled with a computer or phone software, that would be easier.
 
Some pickups and their positioning might not be capable to produce the tone you are looking for. Perhaps you need an equalizer pedal. The tone capacitor in the passive setup does very little. Of course it is possible to put together a filter that can make things better for you but, using a good eq, should be more helpful. Unfortunately, I have not used an eq pedals and have nothing to recommend. Parametric EQ would be ultimately more capable, but it is very difficult to make sense of if you are not familiar with how to use one. Maybe there is an eq pedals which can be controlled with a computer or phone software, that would be easier.

Thank you so much! Great suggestions!
 
I recently replaced the stock pickup on my squire Bronco bass with a Seymour Duncan SCPB-3 Quarter Pound. When I have the tone all the way open (highs) I have plenty of volume. The pickup is super hot. But when I roll the tone off I lose literally almost all of my volume. Could that be a capacitor or potentiometer issue on the standard tone pot?
 

Latest posts