• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Chuck Rainey (tone!)

Ken Smith basses help. They have a natural " R&B" sound to them. Of course, its all in his hands.

His classic work was done on a Fender P-bass.
A discussion/argument I always get into with younger, gear-obsessed players...back in my day, guys could use 'logs' & still make it happen.

More so than hands...it's in his heart, mind & soul.
 
Dont fret CHris, I'm an old fart and would still prefer to hear Chuck on a trebly clanky Jazz... but I like that 70's sound rounds/maple boards with fret noisie...

The Steely Dan song Gaucho, imho, is indicative of Chuck's phat fingered groove, easy, subtle, with just the right amount of ghost notes, etc. In fact, the anal retentive Dan boys must have asked Chuck to clean it up some I''d reckon.

But I can see how he'd gravitate toward Ken Smith basses. They have that signature phat R&B sound, imho.
 
Well, thats the nature of P basses, innit!

Mine isn't (a '64 now outfitted with a Norstrand pickup).

I can see people's point about 'farty' bass tones with someone like Jack Bruce (Gibson bass w/ 2 pickups) & maybe even Jaco (Fender Jazz).
Rainey, Jamerson, Rocco, & the others known for playing early P-basses? I don't hear it.
 
The Steely Dan song Gaucho, imho, is indicative of Chuck's phat fingered groove, easy, subtle, with just the right amount of ghost notes, etc. In fact, the anal retentive Dan boys must have asked Chuck to clean it up some I''d reckon.

The song "Gaucho" is played by Walter Becker.

And maybe it's me (& it usually is)-
I'm not sure Rainey gravitated towards Smith basses...the cynic in me thinks he was given one.
 
Jim, NO WAY. THats not Becker. is it? Holy smokes. With those slides an all. No way, didnt think Becker got that feel at all, unless he learned the song from Chuck. ,

Really, I;m stunned. I;m grabbing my old vinyl " Gaucho" copy right now and checking the liner notes...

HUH, there it is in black and white. I'm stunned. I gotta give Walter props. See I can tell its him on the Everythign Must Go disc, that sounds like Becker to me, pretty "clean", and not a ton of feel.

Wow. Learn something new everyday, and theres my first today. THNX Jim. and Sorry Walt.
 
Mine isn't (a '64 now outfitted with a Norstrand pickup).

I can see people's point about 'farty' bass tones with someone like Jack Bruce (Gibson bass w/ 2 pickups) & maybe even Jaco (Fender Jazz).
Rainey, Jamerson, Rocco, & the others known for playing early P-basses? I don't hear it.

+1. Nothing against Spectors (I'm a huge Doug Wimbish fan) its just I prefer that old school tone of the Aretha/Steely Dan era. The recordings I've heard of him on a Spector just didn't sound that great.