• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Classic Pickup position or Sweet Spot

So I'm building a six sting, and I'm planning on putting a Delano Xtender(s) quad coil in there. I've intend to Ed Friedland playing the Human Bass roxy b5 and it sounds killer, so my question is, put the two hum buckers in classic position (one Bridge one neck) or just have one pickup placed where I discern the sweet spot is? It would save me money, but am I sacrificing a lot of tonal options and possibilities?

I'll post some pictures of the bass as well as I'm building it.
 
Not sure where you feel comfortable playing. You said you're used to a jazz bass, so it may be different for you. But, my favorite basses to player are the single H Stingrays and the duel buckers on the G&L L2K. Those spots are heaven to me.

And yes, I know there are more brands that use the same specs. I'm just used to those 2. The Modulus Flea bass I once had was perfect too.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Raf Seibert
ImageUploadedByTalkBass1401327856.779775.jpg
sweetspot!
 
There's some logic to the sweet spot argument, and I do love a good Precision with only one pickup. But what defines the sweet spot? To me, the P or neck J position is the sweet spot. To Jaco, the bridge J position was the sweet spot. To others, the MM is in the sweet spot. And yes, two pickups can cause phasing issues, but sometimes those phasing issues lead to great tone. And if you so desire, you can turn one or the other off, but with only one, you're locked. Not saying don't do the single pickup. Go with whatever works. Just presenting the other side.
 
There's some logic to the sweet spot argument, and I do love a good Precision with only one pickup. But what defines the sweet spot? To me, the P or neck J position is the sweet spot. To Jaco, the bridge J position was the sweet spot. To others, the MM is in the sweet spot.

I think "sweet spot" generally refers to the MM position. J positions are pretty standard, probably 80-90% of basses have pickups in those locations.
 
The whole "sweet spot" concept only applies if you limit your playing to open strings. As soon as you fret a note, the relationship of the pickup position to the length of the string changes.

It is true that many single-pickup basses sound great, but it's NOT because of a mythical "sweet spot"! ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: downlowuponit
The sweet spot for me is where the right hand technique is the most comfortable, AND the tone has enough "meat" on it. Usually for me this is normally between the jazz pickups or similar spot on any bass. You could also argue that this spot is sweet for tone also, as it has a little of both bridge and neck tonality.
 
So I'm building a six sting, and I'm planning on putting a Delano Xtender(s) quad coil in there. I've intend to Ed Friedland playing the Human Bass roxy b5 and it sounds killer, so my question is, put the two hum buckers in classic position (one Bridge one neck) or just have one pickup placed where I discern the sweet spot is? It would save me money, but am I sacrificing a lot of tonal options and possibilities?

I'll post some pictures of the bass as well as I'm building it.
Where exactly do you see that 'sweet spot'?
 
I feel that a good illustration of the concept is a comparison between the Rickenbacker 425 and 450 models:

mvc090.jpg


Rickenbacker%20450%20-%20Front.jpg


The two-pickup model, like many two-pickup basses, has one pickup very near the bridge and one pickup much further towards the neck; the one-pickup version places that single pickup somewhere in between those two locations.

In my experience, a two-pickup bass gives three distinct tones - a trebly one (bridge only), a fat one (neck only), or a scooped one (both). In contrast, a one-pickup-in-the-sweet-spot yields a tone that is altogether different; it is not as trebly as the bridge location, yet not as boomy as the neck location, but rather seems to have an abundance of crucial mid frequencies. For this reason I tend to conceptualize it as the opposite of the scooped two-pickup tone. Further, a quality two-band preamp seems to be an ideal complement, as it can fill in more low frequencies to approximate a neck pickup, or fill in more high frequencies to approximate a bridge pickup, or yield additional tones that are neither.

Some people espouse the concept of the sweet spot as a mathematical absolute, corresponding to some harmonic antinode or other; this is (as Mushroo pointed out) only applicable if all you play are open strings. The other notion of the sweet spot is much more subjective, and simply means one pickup placed at neither the bridge nor the neck position, but somewhere in between, the location chosen based partly on tone, partly on ergonomics, partly on aesthetics, and partly on tradition (those who emulate the StingRay location, typically).

I like 'em both. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: downlowuponit