• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Clean up classifieds

Potomuss

Supporting Member
Dec 7, 2016
402
766
Peoria, IL
There are so many dead ads in the classifieds that are obviously outdated but remain open. No doubt the number of abandoned ads will always grow. Would it make sense to clean these up a bit? Perhaps identify all ads with no responses or bumps for more than say a year or two and mark them as no longer available? Maybe auto close them by policy after a certain amount of time with no activity? I wouldn't think that most folks actively selling items would be affected by this. In the case of false positive, the user would just have to update the status to re-open the ad. I wouldn't want to see them deleted for the sake of historical reference, but I constantly find myself looking at something still marked for sale and then realizing the ad is from ten years ago and the user has moved on and left their mess. Just a thought.
 
I'll dissent, mildly. To me the historical pricing info and commentary has some value when deciding how to market your gear. The search function allows you to zero in as needed. It's not my memory being taken up, what do I care? :)
This is why I expressly mentioned not deleting the ads, but merely closing them. Then using the filters for only available gear would work even better!
:)
 
Definitely like the idea of listing only being open/valid for 30 days or so. After that, the OP should have to renew.

They also should not return in search results unless specified the user wants to see these. They should also be secondary to active listings.

I'd go so far as to suggest they be moved to their own archive. It's important to see what has come and gone.

Also, have you guys seen items for sale elsewhere? Some things are available for years! I've bought turners from 1+ yr old listings on Reverb and messaged sellers about other items that are still available after the same amount of time. It's bitter sweet. lol