• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

current product offerings?

A couple of questions about current recording software products (from someone who has not used recording software in about 10 years…..)

1. Is there a product that combines

i. a transcribing / composing software like the Finale products, and

ii. a basic recording program

the goal would be to take the rough sketch of a song, created in something like Finale, and replace the written parts with live recorded parts. For example; assume I have created a basic drums, bass and guitar composition by writing out the parts. The Finale type product turns that into a funny sounding but useful approximation of the playback of that written composition. I would then like to replace each of the parts by playing along and overdubbing actual drum, bass and guitar parts.

I know that some products allow me to export a midi file from the written composition that I could then import into a multi-track recording software, but is there a product that makes that step unnecessary? A product that would allow those written tracks to show up as just more tracks on the overall multitrack recording? As I play along and record a live bass part to an unused track, I can then delete the written bass track (or, if I wanted to, keep both versions)

2. back in the real world………what is the simplest, most basic multi-track recording package for use on PC (not MAC)? For a little perspective, what is the 1" eight track of multi-track recording software? A product for someone who will not be altering waveforms, using ANY fx; I just want a basic recording platform that will allow live recording of at least 4 to 6 tracks and the ability to overdub a couple of more tracks. Except for the request in #1 above, all recording will be actual live recording = instrument into mic into preamp into recording software. And while the initial use will be for building up compositions one track at a time, the ultimate goal would be for this same product to work well when recording a live band (and yes, 6 simultaneous live tracks is MORE than enough for a basic r&b combo). Suggestions?