• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Eminenece vs. Celestion

Has anyone else noticed that Eminence seems to be the main contender in bass speakers, yet Celestion seems to hold that position for guitar? They each make both kinds of speakers yet seem to have their own niche in the market. Anyway, I was just wondering if it was just me or if that really was the case...

Brian
 
Has anyone used any Celestion speakers recently? I ask because I'm a fan of 10" drivers, but the Eminence Basslites handle comparatively less power (150W RMS... compared to Celestion's 200-300W RMS). But like you said, Celestion doesn't post much in the way of information about the speakers...

Brian
 
I can only speak for their conventional 15's - not the neo's here;

But when I made up my 15" cabs I had many people advise me to go Eminence.
I did the math through WinISD and the like - and the math told me to go Eminence.
I then worked out the cost - and that told me Eminence too.

3 out of 3 ain't bad.;)

Things may have changed in the last 5 years with all the neo speakers becoming popular and all - but I doubt Eminence would have just dropped the ball.
 
Has anyone used any Celestion speakers recently? I ask because I'm a fan of 10" drivers, but the Eminence Basslites handle comparatively less power (150W RMS... compared to Celestion's 200-300W RMS). But like you said, Celestion doesn't post much in the way of information about the speakers...

Brian

Celestions > Eminence IMHO. I think the Green Label celestions are some of the nicest vintage-replacement speakers around. Also I'm pretty sure some Eminence's hand 200+ watts, but I haven't really been satisfied with the new 200+ watt ones. I think they loose sound quality.
 
Has anyone else noticed that Eminence seems to be the main contender in bass speakers, yet Celestion seems to hold that position for guitar? They each make both kinds of speakers yet seem to have their own niche in the market. Anyway, I was just wondering if it was just me or if that really was the case...

Brian

Works for me, Delta Lites for Bass, V30s for guitar :)
 
Celestions > Eminence IMHO. I think the Green Label celestions are some of the nicest vintage-replacement speakers around. Also I'm pretty sure some Eminence's hand 200+ watts, but I haven't really been satisfied with the new 200+ watt ones. I think they loose sound quality.

where have you heard the green labels? i emailed them when the first did that press released and they wrote back and said that it was just sortr of a teaser to the public. ***? havent seen the for sale or listed on their site, though I havent looked in a while.

JR
 
Has anyone else noticed that Eminence seems to be the main contender in bass speakers, yet Celestion seems to hold that position for guitar? They each make both kinds of speakers yet seem to have their own niche in the market. Anyway, I was just wondering if it was just me or if that really was the case...

Brian
In the US Eminences are excellent value for money, hence they're used a lot. But there are a ton of other brands / models that are as good or better that I personally lean towards based upon performance and local price and availability.

Having built a few combos and heads for guitarists, I know how much more brand-centric they tend to be. Usually I find it's an automatic Gibson / Marshall / SD / Celestion are the best! or slight variations depending upon their individual biasses. Without knowing what it is and using ears only, I've surprised a few with other brands/models they may not have considered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexanderB
Right now I'm running 2 Eminence delta 12", 8 ohm drivers in an old mid 70's Ampeg V-4 cab. I also just found and ordered a new (used) set of Celestion 12", 8 ohm pulse bass speakers to complete the cabinet. I'm mainly a Rickenbacker bass player 4001, 4003 basses with an occasional appearance by one of my jazz basses. The 74 4001 has hi gain pickups in the bridge and neck positions. The 96 4003 has been modified. I installed the .047 Ric cap on thd bridge tone pot to get "that" old Ric clank. I then installed a new style horseshoe pickup in the bridge and removed the cover. I then installed a toaster neck pickup. Both basses also have been fitted with the Badass 1 bass bridge. (I can put both basses back to normal by reinstalling the orig bridge. I run Rotosound round wound stainless steel strings on all of my basses. The fenders also have badass bridges and Rotosound round wound stainless steel strings also. I had a pickup maker from texas design a set of j bass pickups that come very close to that Ric strong mid-range presence and clarity of a Ric pickup. I also run an old Sunn S-200 tube head and cab with 2-jbl 15" drivers. I run all basses through a Sansamp RPM rack mount preamp. The head for the 4-12" cab is either an old Marshall JTM 45 or a Laney GH 50 L. I get either Geddy Lee's tone with the 74 Ric or j basses or i get Paul De Amour's tone ( from old Tool, think sober) with the 96 4003. Wow! I just went the LONG way around to say that the Eminence 12's sound wonderful and clear. The 15" JBL's are always running completely clean and dry. I get the thundering lows out of them. The 12's always run with some OD and or FX. The Eminences handle it all very well. I'm praying that the Celestion pulse speakers will turn out to be a good compliment to the Eminence speakers. Not many bass players use 12's. They have no idea what they are missing! If you don't run 15's, the best thing i can say is they have the attack of the 10's and the warm depth of the 15's. I'll never run another 10" speaker in my chain again. If I don't feel like lugging around the 15's, the 12's cover the Terrain of both 10 and 15 inch speakers easily. You can't go wrong with the Eminence 12's. Period!
 
I can see, so much advantage to eminence, the true celestion are pioneers on bass response, You can see the parameters.. i had an ampeg 410bxt, but i have clear celestion sound in my mind are too big ( soundstage)(psychoacoustic) and only can be experienced ... Trace Elliot. And i miss so much my DL8s.. ppl who change the drivers of his Cerwin Vega and said its too much punch. It's what it's.. only want a pulse 15 and 2 pulse 10. Celestion line array full range for "treblee". And the wattage it's very very modest. If it i'll -3db rating at 320 watt on 90s 1048 model now says 800 watt. Maybe it's the peak. Or capable of erogate 1600 peak...
Only need celestion in my life, eminence it's kinda nationalism.. but have less good performance.. :)
By sensibility and that "3D" sound.. every celestion have.
They stablished the STD 4x10 and 15" at bottom
 
Last edited:
I can see, so much advantage to eminence, the true celestion are pioneers on bass response
Are they? Would you care to post one of their pioneering bass drivers so that we can compare to other drivers of the day and before?
 

Latest posts