• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Ever been in a horrible but fun band?

A drummer friend knowing I was bandless but looking to just play music invited me to join his jam band.

Turns out it's a lot of fun, but, man, where do I start?

The drummer and I, do click, we aren't perfect, I sometimes hit the wrong fret, he loses his sticks, no big deal.

The singer is plain bad, does not want to take lessons, had to tell him to stop using his chest voice to sing high and instead to use falsetto, he never heard of it. Guy is very loopy and goofy, but it's a show in itself. He is delusional but very positive. Most of the time I tune him out, often I pay attention because he is so entertaining.

The guitarist is a good guy who's been hit hard by the economy and considers himself poor. Drummer and I have helped him a few times. Let's say he has issues. After 2 months playing together he asks me what kind of pick do I use. Except that I am a 100% finger style player. But he knows all the classic, note for note, it's eerie.

The Nuge, The Who, Led Zeppellin, The Eagles, Molly Hatchet, Joe Walsh, Pink Floyd, Skynyrd, he's like a classic rock jukebox. He does an incredible Stranglehold. I take this opportunity to really learn and master all these great classic tunes.

But after 2 open mics, I am wondering how many Spinal Tap moments am I going to witness. I am actually having a lot of fun. It's like an awkard trainwreck where you can tell there is a certain amount of talent, but the whole thing is overall very goofy and that's part of what makes it fun.

But the point is: I have been in a few bands where there was a lot of talent, but also a lot of ego. And most of these bands disbanded before ever playing one single gig. Some lasted 6 months, which were 6 months of musical direction bickering while auditioning for the same position, because we could not either keep a drummer or a guitar player or a singer.

But these guys have absolutely no complex at all, do it for fun, and after not even 2 months since I joined, we're on stage playing open mics, and pretty soon even some little paid gigs. Kid you not, people want to pay us to play.

Seriously, we've heard both good and bad reviews from the audience. Some people even friended us the same evening writing that we were a lot of fun and asking for gig dates. If they were joking, or not, I don't know :)

Has anyone been in this situation? Where the "talented", serious musicians can't get it done, while the average or below average musicians have no issues doing it, and on top of it, it's so much fun at so many levels?
 
I'm below average and talented/serious musicians aren't interested in letting me play with them. So I find other musicians with similar talent (or lack of) and we have fun. Haven't done a real paid gig yet but we have played for food/beer/tips and had a blast.
 
Hold on to these guys. Seriously.

I really hadn't played seriously for over 20 years. Now I've been rehearsing (and gigging) with a couple of guys who are about the same station in life--we're all in our 30's/40's, established, have regular jobs so no pressure to make lots of money...

....we're in it for the fun of it, and having a blast. :bassist:

The guys are more than willing to drill through the same changes over and over to help me solidify a part, listen through my bumbling solos, and are constantly encouraging.

As a group we're progressing rather rapidly. A part of this is on account of the fact we have nothing to prove, so we know when something sucks and get over it. We've got good enough relationships that we can call each other out (good-naturedly) when someone misses something and work to improve it the next time--no egos, no drama.

Sure, you'll have "spinal tap" moments, but I think you'll find them fewer and more far between as you guys work together.

And as you do this, people see you having fun--and you probably have some decent stage presence because of that. That's why they want to book you, even if you flub some notes sometimes. Performance is 90% visual anyway. Sad but true.

I remember sitting in a workshop with the Ray Brown Trio, and the Drummer (Jeff Hamilton at that time) commented to all of us collegate music wannabees--"We tend to forget the reason we got involved in music in the first place is to have fun."

So have fun! :D

Edit: Oh, and you probably don't sound as bad as you think. That you recognize this means you guys *can* get a lot better, over time. You may reach a point where you're playing circles around some bands you thought had monster players, but they will never play well together and will never progress because they lack humility and the maturity to grow.

At least...you'll be getting gigs that they might not... ;)
 
Nope, can't say that I have. That's awesome though. I wish I had some guys like that to play with. Actually, I've been in situations like you mentioned with bands that had all the talent in the world, and the ego to go along with it, and never got off the ground. I was with one band for 4 years and did a grand total of 4 gigs. These guys were great guys and very, very talented players but that's arbitrary if nobody hears you. We stayed in a makeshift studio for 3 of those 4 years and in a room inside an office building for the last year. They're still together as far as I know but I had to leave that band before I went nuts.

This band I'm in now I've been in for almost 2 years. We did one gig so far but have recorded 20+ songs. The band leader owns a studio here in town and has had some big names in there before. So far I haven't outgrown my stay but I'm almost there. Good thing we've got a CD in the process of coming out or I'd probably be gone already.
 
I can't recall who said it, but I remember reading an interview with a well known bassist years ago, who said he used the 3 point system to determine whether a band was going to work for him or not.

The points are:

- Great music
- Great money
- Great hang, meaning he dug the players and had fun doing it.

If 2 of these were happening, it was workable.

I think there's a lot of truth in that.

If you get a gig with all 3, hang onto it for the rest of your life because they are few and far between.

:)
 
I've subbed for 2 such bands. If you aren't afraid of looking stupid on stage, it really is a gas. (The leader of the country band got me drunk as hell on Jack Daniels as we butchered Hank Williams and Dwight Yoakam songs for money)
 
Stay with it. If you guys are happy hanging out and playing music, just hang out and play and count your blessings. The audience is obviously picking up on your good vibe.

if the choice is between good MUSICIANS or GOOD musicians to play with, I'll always choose the latter.

.
 
Being in a fun band that happens to be horrible can be a really liberating experience. You learn not to take yourself so seriously, not worry about every little note, nuance, etc, and just HAVE A BLAST!

I was in a band like this for a little while back in high school. They were called "Son of Spam". They mainly played punk covers (NOFX, Ramones, Rancid, etc..). I was brought on toward the end of the band's reign of terror (as a drummer), and there was never a dull moment. Trademarks of this band's shows were out of tune & very aggressive guitar, out of tune & very aggressive bass, and a big, mean looking "co-lead" singer.. Who really just stood there, got really drunk, and sang loud, out of tune, obnoxious backing vocals (sometimes in falsetto) riddled with profanity. It was just the cure for someone like me, who thought that every note had to be in perfect time, perfect tune, etc..

I remember the last gig I ever played with them, it was an "End of School Year" bash we were throwing - we rented the auditorium in the civic center and everything!

A week or so earlier, the lead singer/guitarist's girlfriend dumped him, and he didn't take it so well. He ended up cutting himself up pretty badly, and was now in the hospital being monitored, because they thought he was going to try to commit suicide.

The band paid pretty big money to rent this hall we were playing, and there was just no way we could do any of the songs without the lead singer. So, we had to do sumthin' bad.

We dropped off our gear at the hall, and the 4 of us got in the van, drove to the hospital and snuck him out. Well, sort of...

We played the whole night without incident, and I don't think anyone even asked us why our lead singer was in a hospital gown and ID bracelet. It was probably the tightest and most entertaining show we'd ever played, but we still totally sucked! Only, we sucked in a loud, obnoxious, aggressive, making everyone dance, kind of way. It was awesome!

One of the best nights of my HS days... Until we tried to sneak the singer back into the hospital, where we had to explain our actions to some cops who just happened to be looking for us all night.

Horrible bands ROCK! :bassist:
 
You're having fun.
You're learning some cool tunes.
The whole band is having a good time, and not taking themselves too seriously.
Youre also learning some group and stage dynamics outside of your normal 'box'.
You're even getting paid.

How can it be bad?
Just keep going and you may be known as your area's most fun party band, even develop a good following.
 
winner.gif

Being in a fun band that happens to be horrible can be a really liberating experience. You learn not to take yourself so seriously, not worry about every little note, nuance, etc, and just HAVE A BLAST!

I was in a band like this for a little while back in high school. They were called "Son of Spam". They mainly played punk covers (NOFX, Ramones, Rancid, etc..). I was brought on toward the end of the band's reign of terror (as a drummer), and there was never a dull moment. Trademarks of this band's shows were out of tune & very aggressive guitar, out of tune & very aggressive bass, and a big, mean looking "co-lead" singer.. Who really just stood there, got really drunk, and sang loud, out of tune, obnoxious backing vocals (sometimes in falsetto) riddled with profanity. It was just the cure for someone like me, who thought that every note had to be in perfect time, perfect tune, etc..

I remember the last gig I ever played with them, it was an "End of School Year" bash we were throwing - we rented the auditorium in the civic center and everything!

A week or so earlier, the lead singer/guitarist's girlfriend dumped him, and he didn't take it so well. He ended up cutting himself up pretty badly, and was now in the hospital being monitored, because they thought he was going to try to commit suicide.

The band paid pretty big money to rent this hall we were playing, and there was just no way we could do any of the songs without the lead singer. So, we had to do sumthin' bad.

We dropped off our gear at the hall, and the 4 of us got in the van, drove to the hospital and snuck him out. Well, sort of...

We played the whole night without incident, and I don't think anyone even asked us why our lead singer was in a hospital gown and ID bracelet. It was probably the tightest and most entertaining show we'd ever played, but we still totally sucked! Only, we sucked in a loud, obnoxious, aggressive, making everyone dance, kind of way. It was awesome!

One of the best nights of my HS days... Until we tried to sneak the singer back into the hospital, where we had to explain our actions to some cops who just happened to be looking for us all night.

Horrible bands ROCK! :bassist:
You, sir, are my HERO!
2403_worshipper.gif
 
Being in a fun band that happens to be horrible can be a really liberating experience. You learn not to take yourself so seriously, not worry about every little note, nuance, etc, and just HAVE A BLAST!

I was in a band like this for a little while back in high school. They were called "Son of Spam". They mainly played punk covers (NOFX, Ramones, Rancid, etc..). I was brought on toward the end of the band's reign of terror (as a drummer), and there was never a dull moment. Trademarks of this band's shows were out of tune & very aggressive guitar, out of tune & very aggressive bass, and a big, mean looking "co-lead" singer.. Who really just stood there, got really drunk, and sang loud, out of tune, obnoxious backing vocals (sometimes in falsetto) riddled with profanity. It was just the cure for someone like me, who thought that every note had to be in perfect time, perfect tune, etc..

I remember the last gig I ever played with them, it was an "End of School Year" bash we were throwing - we rented the auditorium in the civic center and everything!

A week or so earlier, the lead singer/guitarist's girlfriend dumped him, and he didn't take it so well. He ended up cutting himself up pretty badly, and was now in the hospital being monitored, because they thought he was going to try to commit suicide.

The band paid pretty big money to rent this hall we were playing, and there was just no way we could do any of the songs without the lead singer. So, we had to do sumthin' bad.

We dropped off our gear at the hall, and the 4 of us got in the van, drove to the hospital and snuck him out. Well, sort of...

We played the whole night without incident, and I don't think anyone even asked us why our lead singer was in a hospital gown and ID bracelet. It was probably the tightest and most entertaining show we'd ever played, but we still totally sucked! Only, we sucked in a loud, obnoxious, aggressive, making everyone dance, kind of way. It was awesome!

One of the best nights of my HS days... Until we tried to sneak the singer back into the hospital, where we had to explain our actions to some cops who just happened to be looking for us all night.

Horrible bands ROCK! :bassist:

Now That's Punk!
 
Horrible <> Fun

Mediocre/energetic/entertaining - - sure. But horrible?

I was briefly in a *horrible* band - - on lead guitar. I couldn't take it - - I thought it would be a great excuse to get my guitar chops up to speed... but I just couldn't take it...
 
There are two types of bands: Serious and not serious.

A serious band is like a professional sports team. They practice practice practice. Sometimes practice is not fun and is more like work. But they get better.

A not serious band is like a group of guys playing sandlot football. They drink a few beers and toss the bass around. If they get better it is a complete accident. But they have fun.

I have been in both bands and they both have their advantages and disadvantages.

One band I was in started out fun but I got tired of the lack of discipline/leadership. They goofed around and never got any better. It was fun but I soon got tired of playing simple songs poorly, so I quit. I saw them years later and they were still making the same stupid mistakes they were making when I was with them. They get a few gigs but could actually get more if they worked at getting better.

So it all depends on what YOU want to get out of the band. In my case I wanted to try different music and challenge myself to grow musically.