• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Favorite Crooner ?

Since Benedetto is your favourite, give me a "must hear" album to find please and thanks.
This is the record that re-launched his career...1994. Perhaps, without it, he'd be a full time painter today. It solidly lands inside the top dozen albums we own.
tony bennett unplugged.jpg


basie bennett.jpg
...
tony bennett bill evans 2.jpg
...
bennett brubeck.jpg
...a few thoughts...

I don't think he ever has been a full frontal Jazz singer...Ella Fitzgerald, Mel Torme, Lena Horne, Louis Armstrong, Diana Krall...but, Man! he could make a song his own. Lots of people think "They Can't Take That Away From Me" is a Frank Sinatra song...not me;)


I'm really glad to see Dean Martin getting some love out here...cool to see Vic Fontaine mentioned, too!
 
Was Joe Williams a crooner? He did some crooning, but I'm not sure I'd box him in like that. OTOH, no greater frontman ever presided over a swank orchestra.

Now, this is most def NOT one of his crooning numbers, but hey, it's a must. Bonus points that bassist is the legendary Carol Kaye laying down an impossibly hip 1973 groove.

If you don't like this you can PM me and we'll set up a date so you can punch me in the face and film it for YouTube.

 
Last edited:
Chet Baker's melancholy cool crooning really gets to me. He doesn't embellish anything, only renders the tune and lyrics so plainly and sensitively. - Oh, and k.d. lang on her torchier material - I've hardly heard a better singer for virtues like pitch, breath control, vibrato and dynamics.
 
Last edited:
I think if Lady Gaga decided to play it seriously, she'd be the next best female crooner in the world.

Oh, and k.d. lang on her torchier material - I've hardly heard a better singer for virtues like pitch, breath control, vibrato and dynamics.

...and WHO made records with both of these extraordinary ladies?
......Anthony Benedetto!

He described Lady Gaga as one of the finest artists he'd ever known...and this!!! from a guy who knew Ella!!!

I don't own any Lady Gaga albums, but I do own 6 by k.d. lang...
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregC and Tom Bomb
He didn't have the best voice in the world, but no one used their voice as an instrument like Sinatra.

His voice on the 1943+ Columbia recordings sound somewhat different than it did after his throat hemorrhaged in 1950, wherein one could detect an ever so slight weathering of his voice that wasn't there before.

I don't know if that changed his phrasing or not, but to me his tone and phrasing became more to my liking.

I think I read somewhere that he did have surgery on it, but I'm not sure.
 
Now that I think of it, this is truly a tough thread for me to answer to as there are so many male and female vocalists who also crooned, that I like, past and present.
...

Frank Sinatra is quoted as saying Lou Rawls had "the classiest singing and silkiest chops in the singing game."

Yep, he was another one that made it sound so easy.

I was at Western Studios in the 70's and some guy walked in the room and asked in a low-pitched voice if he could hide out for a few minutes, as some girls had followed him in the building and he wanted to ditch them.

I thought to myself that's gotta be Lou Rawls. I turned around to face this guy and sure enough, it was him!
 
Melody Gardot, my goodness,









Oh yeah; for those of you not familiar with her, the sunglasses at night and odd posturing thing are not some kind of hipster affectations. She was a pedestrian hit-and-run victim, essentially left for dead, and had to endure a long period of reconstructive surgery and physical therapy, during which time she delved deep into music for relief. She is light sensitive, and has to sit in a certain way in a specially built chair on stage. Very smokey, Nina Simone-esque voice. Now, while I enjoy and respect all of the aforementioned old-school singers, I'd have to nominate the Walker Brother's Scott Walker from earlier in his career. I won't cite the usual suspect "The Sun Ain't Gonna Shine Anymore", which was their only hit in the US(although they were huge in the UK with many smashes). Instead, I offer this Bacharach/David melodrama...

He later went solo, and issued a number of atmospheric artsy albums, this tune being a good example...


His career and art in the last 25-30 years has taken a very experimental and challenging(to say the least)path, probably an acquired taste for most, and his voice has gone through the changes to be expected with age, but I dig the stuff on its own merits, and he has found a new audience. This weighty piece from his more recent era may be the most accessible example I could come up with...


But if you're not afraid of getting way out there(and believe me, it can get even more extreme), try this on for size...