I started thread with my question and didn't get any responses so figured I would ask here.
background:
I used to have an older export Aerodyne ("S" serial number). Back of neck was slightly stained which I liked and a thick rosewood fretboard. The sound of the P pickup was very punchy and open (sounded like most other P pickups).
Current question/concern/issue:
I have noticed in multiple newer export aerodynes ("JD15-19" serial number) that the sound is very dark and dull, to the point that it is a turnoff off for me, although they play exactly the same as the older ones.
Recent example was I was in my local GC and they had both a used "S" serial and a new "JD19" I played back to back. Both felt great, but the newer one still had a dull/dark sound whereas the older one had that typical punchy open P sound. Unfortunately, the older one had a ski jump on the neck. The new one played great.
Has anyone else noticed this? Am I just going crazy? Could this be remedied with different pots or pickups? Why would they sound so different?
background:
I used to have an older export Aerodyne ("S" serial number). Back of neck was slightly stained which I liked and a thick rosewood fretboard. The sound of the P pickup was very punchy and open (sounded like most other P pickups).
Current question/concern/issue:
I have noticed in multiple newer export aerodynes ("JD15-19" serial number) that the sound is very dark and dull, to the point that it is a turnoff off for me, although they play exactly the same as the older ones.
Recent example was I was in my local GC and they had both a used "S" serial and a new "JD19" I played back to back. Both felt great, but the newer one still had a dull/dark sound whereas the older one had that typical punchy open P sound. Unfortunately, the older one had a ski jump on the neck. The new one played great.
Has anyone else noticed this? Am I just going crazy? Could this be remedied with different pots or pickups? Why would they sound so different?




