• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Flat Speakers

I heard of this comming, they are not for high power apps, but the "speaker" we are all used to is VERY old tech. Just bare in mind what people would have said in the days of large box tube type TV's (with small screens) if you put up the idea of a flat panel color TV you could hang on the wall?
 
"Another great application would be in PA systems for public spaces," says Steve. "The sound produced by FFLs can be directed straight at its intended audience. The sound volume and quality does not deteriorate as it does in conventional speakers, which means that public announcements in passenger terminals, for example, could be clearer, crisper, and easier to hear."

Fair enough... but that's about all these types of speakers are good for. You can make a simpler version yourself:-



Notice this guy claims "Hi-Fi" as well. Have a listen for yourself........and try not to laugh too hard ok!
 
Just bare in mind what people would have said in the days of large box tube type TV's (with small screens) if you put up the idea of a flat panel color TV you could hang on the wall?
There is a episode of twilight zone where the "so called" ugly women is supposed to be getting plastic surgery but it doesn't work. you know the one where everyone has the distorted pig faces, well when she runs down the hall there is a row of flat screen monitors hanging on the wall! this was the mid sixties!!!
 
Looks quite similar to the old Magnepan ribbon speaker technology to me.( The originals are known as the Magneplanar.)
Wouldn't be my first choice for high volume applications. It is interesting, but I'd wait to see how this technology holds up under field conditions.
 
way back when. I tried them with my bass for jazz, and they were pretty amazing. Very natural, like a huge upright. However, they produce sound from so much area that they do not sound loud up close, but they fill up a room quickly, much like the Bose towers. I doubt they could work for rock, or any type of large flat speaker, but for a natural sound I think flat speakers would work great.
 
I see no way of applying this idea to bass reproduction. So called planar speakers are already with us. My son has a pair, from a now defunct Canadian company, on his computer. They are good for mid and high frequencies but imagine how much the samwitch would have to bend in order to reproduce a low B.

Paul
 
I dont think we will see this as a praticle bass application anytime soon, but if it were possible, id be down. Imagine it, instead of lugging your 8x10 fridge up stairs, in a car, out of the car, up/down more stairs, setup in your venue, then do it all over again when you packup, all you have to do is pound a tack in the wall and hang a tapestry.....awwweeesome.

tho im with Bassmanpaul on this, I dont see bass applications with this anytime in the near future.