• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

For all you players that use a low B string - a trivia question

Some various info came up in a recent thread over in the 'Amps and Cabs' forum. And I was just wondering how many 5er / 6er players that use a low B, actually knew this tidbit of information. Not particularly useful in gigging/chops terms, but possibly if designing rigs and systems. Also for its use as a reference for where the low B lies in the scope of human hearing.

Answer truthfully. Do you know what frequency the open low B is relative to Hz. I'm certain someone will pop in with the answer pretty quickly. Mainly I was wondering how many of us knew. I didn't, tho it meshed closely with the guess I would have made.

In addition, how many keys on a standard 88 key piano are actually lower than this?
 
I knew it was 31Hz, but then I've also been playing 5+ strings for 19 of my 20 years of playing. A lot of folks also don't realize how few cabs can actually reproduce the fundamental of the low B, and many of the cabs that do use 10" speakers rather than larger ones that many think would be more appropriate.
 
Some various info came up in a recent thread over in the 'Amps and Cabs' forum. And I was just wondering how many 5er / 6er players that use a low B, actually knew this tidbit of information. Not particularly useful in gigging/chops terms, but possibly if designing rigs and systems. Also for its use as a reference for where the low B lies in the scope of human hearing.

Answer truthfully. Do you know what frequency the open low B is relative to Hz. I'm certain someone will pop in with the answer pretty quickly. Mainly I was wondering how many of us knew. I didn't, tho it meshed closely with the guess I would have made.

In addition, how many keys on a standard 88 key piano are actually lower than this?
I don't know and I don't care how or why. I just know it's sounds good
 
You need a Acme Low B cab to get the "brown note"
 

Attachments

  • DSCN1084.JPG
    DSCN1084.JPG
    1.6 MB · Views: 154
Yes, I knew it was 31 (30.9) Hz, but was not intentionally researching the pitch / hz dynamic, I just happened to stumble across it when creating custom balanced tension string sets. D'addarrio has a chart that references all the pitches (notes and hz) from a 6 String bass up to the 4th fret (I think) of the high e on a guitar.

After learning the frequency range I then started looking at what cabs can handle 31 hz. Most seem to be limited to around 40 hz, if I recall correctly.

On an 88 key Piano, I do not recall how many keys but its not very many 4-5 white keys off the top of my head.

edit: I didn't know it was 30.87... but how many decimals do we need to go to really know :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: GisserD
I know about low B, but what frequency is the brown note?

The resonant frequency of the human thorax is 10-11 hz....a handful of respiratory clearance devices is based on this characteristic. Don't know if the abdominal cavity shares similar properties. I think we can pull off the same thing with drop-tuning, a decent bass rig, and add the lunch buffet at Nawab Indian Restaurant.

Riis
 

Latest posts