• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

GAS Strikes Again

Should I just stick with Fretless Fender Jazz or get a...

  • I banes SRF705

    Votes: 2 8.3%
  • Carvin B50

    Votes: 1 4.2%
  • G&L L-1500

    Votes: 6 25.0%
  • Stick to my excellent Fender Jazz

    Votes: 15 62.5%

  • Total voters
    24

Dr. Cheese

Supporting Member
Mar 3, 2004
57,282
120,407
Metro St. Louis
Last week, I played three nights of revival and a long Easter program. I found myself very satisfied with my current lineup of a Fretless Fender Jazz and. Yamaha BbN5. My Yamaha is new, and I have to tweak my amp more to get its slap tone to come alive, but the finger tone is already happening which is cool because I slap less now than at any time in the last thirty years. My fretless Jazz is simply one of my all time favorite instruments, period! If I crank the mids, my Jazz will smoke anything I have ever heard. That said, I really find myself wanting a fretless five obvious reasons. Although, I sound great on my Jazz in standard tuning or DGCF, I do miss the extra range a five would give me. Part of me, however, says just be happy with what I have and hold on to my pennies. The other GAS-sy part of me is looking at a Ibanez SRF705, a fretless Carvin B50, or fretless G&L L-1500 like the one I had about eight years ago that I should have kept.

Oh well, I guess some things never change.
 
Last edited:
I should have said a fretless G&L L-1505.

Well I have to vote for them all! As a serious GASer I have to say that my main 5er axes are my G&L L2500. I have one in fretted, one in fretless and one bar bass (Tribby). So you might think that's my vote, but good as that is, I have recently acquired and Ibanez SR206 and SR506 in fretted. Those two basses are so different from my G&Ls yet blow me right away! I'm having a SERIOUS GAS attack trying to somehow turn those into a fretted-fretless pair. But that isn't all. The Carvin basses are to die for! I don't have one of those but I do have a Carvin AC50 and the workmanship is just astounding. How could you go wrong with that? And sure I've got a Fender too. Hey nothing does the Fender look and sound than a Fender. It's not my favorite, but like you I've all ready got it, it plays and sounds great so why switch?

The bottom line is you've got a serious GAS problem here and since I've got a very similar one, I"m thinking the only answer is to BUY THEM ALL! :)

I will say that I only do 5ers and more now and hence recommend that, but that probably way back when I was changing from 4s if I had thought of DGCF tuning I might not be such a 5er fanboi now. But it's too late for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
Well I have to vote for them all! As a serious GASer I have to say that my main 5er axes are my G&L L2500. I have one in fretted, one in fretless and one bar bass (Tribby). So you might think that's my vote, but good as that is, I have recently acquired and Ibanez SR206 and SR506 in fretted. Those two basses are so different from my G&Ls yet blow me right away! I'm having a SERIOUS GAS attack trying to somehow turn those into a fretted-fretless pair. But that isn't all. The Carvin basses are to die for! I don't have one of those but I do have a Carvin AC50 and the workmanship is just astounding. How could you go wrong with that? And sure I've got a Fender too. Hey nothing does the Fender look and sound than a Fender. It's not my favorite, but like you I've all ready got it, it plays and sounds great so why switch?

The bottom line is you've got a serious GAS problem here and since I've got a very similar one, I"m thinking the only answer is to BUY THEM ALL! :)

I will say that I only do 5ers and more now and hence recommend that, but that probably way back when I was changing from 4s if I had thought of DGCF tuning I might not be such a 5er fanboi now. But it's too late for me.

I had been playing fives since 1987 before I realized that I could really enjoy DGCF tuning. A five is more versatile, but dropping down a half step is great, especially on a 22 or 24 fret bass. My poor Fender only 20 frets.:(
 
Quit buying cheap basses and save up a get a really nice piece. It's cheaper in the long run because you're not always wanting something new.

G&L and Carvin are really nice basses, they just are not very expensive. I'm sure a bass like a Sadowsky or Xotic would be great, but when I owned boutiques years ago, my GAS never went away either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thechillinvillain
I appreciates the responses. Fretless has given me a new lease on life when it comes to my bass playing. I always loved fretless, but until I got my Fender, intonation was my greatest fear. From the first time I ever played it out, I was struck by little I went out of tune. Fretless has really given me something new after three decades of slap heavy funk.

As I said before, I am keeping the Fender, I honestly could not ask for more in a bass. I don't know if all MIM Fender Jazz fretlesses are that good, or if I just got lucky. Mine is a Sixtieth Anniversary Edition, if that means anything. I I get a new five, I will get the a Ibanez or a Carvin because the quality for under $900 can't be beat. I just don't want to get into a hurry, it's not like someone has a pile if money for me to out on the road or studio with a new fretless.:smug:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doctor_Clock
I think this answers your question.
Yes, I custom ordered a sea foam green fretless L-1505, and it was killer. A local female bassist ended up with it, and told me that there was no way she would sell it back!

I just gave up on that bass when I was badly out of tune when I played it with my choir. Ordering another one would be cool, but it would probably put me several hundreds dollars past my budget.
 

Latest posts