My experience is that most audience members want to hear songs they are familiar with rather than originals. In my current band we play only covers, and concentrate on 50's, 60's, and 70's music. Our target audience remembers those songs and they want to hear them again.
With my previous band, which was Bluegrass and Americana, we would usually mix in 2 or 3 originals, but again the vast majority of songs we played were covers. With that being said, it's not just originals bands that are suffering now. Before Covid, my current band typically played about 40 dates a year, while taking off every January and February to work on new material. We were constantly getting calls from repeat venues wanting to schedule us; now most of them won't even call us back when we call them. So what has changed; Covid has pretty much killed the market for live music in my area, and I don't see a recovery any time soon.
Thump on,
One_Dude
With my previous band, which was Bluegrass and Americana, we would usually mix in 2 or 3 originals, but again the vast majority of songs we played were covers. With that being said, it's not just originals bands that are suffering now. Before Covid, my current band typically played about 40 dates a year, while taking off every January and February to work on new material. We were constantly getting calls from repeat venues wanting to schedule us; now most of them won't even call us back when we call them. So what has changed; Covid has pretty much killed the market for live music in my area, and I don't see a recovery any time soon.
Thump on,
One_Dude