Well i decided to spend the week trying out various chorus pedals from either the store or people i know that have them on their pedal boards....
Keep in mind these are all commercially available pedals under $200.00 (no boutique stuff here)
I used to own a EH Clone Theory and though i was mostly happy with it it was very noisy and didn't really handle low frequencies well especially tuned BEAD DGCF and C#F#BE (yea i play a lot of stoner metal away from the bar) so i got rid of it and never looked back, however as of late i find myself needing one for some Tool songs and a few other things i have been toying with (side project) long story short i came here looking for help....really didn't get much so off i went.
EH Small Clone and Nano Clone like the size and casing but again very noisy and with very low notes they might as well not be turned on (i have yet to use an EH pedal that i really like)
Next the Boss Family
I tried the CH1, the CE-5 and the CEB-3 in a word they were ok but they sound.... well, mechanical and over processed is the best term i can come up with and again they just don't seem to be able to deal with double and triple stops very well to my ears. Not to mention i'm not a big fan of their box design or colors although they seem well made and have a fine reputation.
Next The Digitech Family
I tried the Digitech XBC which sounds ok handles the lows a little better than the Boss pedals did but after all wasn't it designed for bass? however it sounded like somebody put a pillow over my amp basically kind of muddy though lush especially with its multi voice feature. So i moved on to the Digitech CF7 wow much better sound and a lot of tone and speed and depth options....however this was its downfall it does too many things well which meant i kept playing with the settings so much to the point that i got frustrated, and much like the boss Pedals i don't like the box design or the way you have to replace the battery (not that would use a battery) arrgghh really wanted to give up at this point.
I have decided i don't like digital
Moved on to the MXR M-134, like the housing color puts me off but that is minor. overall i liked it except that it seemed to liiterally suck tone on certain notes, and when i tried to correct for tone it also seemed to be very muddy to my ears. but overall better than anything else i tried.
but more to try....
found a Dan Electro DC-1 Cool Cat in a pawn shop...very cheesy looking nice heavy cast casing but the knobs suck and i don't like the switch. Sound was passable but it was fairly beat up and they wanted too much for it...i moved on
BBE Mind Bender....wow I'm thinking analog is the way to go cool casing, i like the box design however; it is combined with a vibrato and instead of having two stomps for each effect it only has one which you have to tap or double tap...the LEDS are bright, but one is yellow and the other green, to close in color and a pain in the backside to deal with, but it seems to handle anything i can throw at it, also nice and quiet..... made a note and set it aside (really wish it had separate controls)
Voodoo Labs Analog Chorus big fan of their Sparkle drive so what the heck.....wow again analog is the way to go can handle anything i throw at it blends well with my overdrive and fuzz i think i have found my pedal although it also seems to suck a little treble...but more to try.
EBS Uni Chorus....man you guys were not kidding it sounds quite lush maybe too lush to my ears it does not sound as good as the Mind Bender with my gear and current set up. I like the color, casing, and switch, also with its features it like having three pedals in one and much easier to switch between features than the Mind Bender. This has just become more difficult but will i ever use the pitch modulation or the flange?
Dunlop Uni Vibe Stereo Chorus- Overall i like this pedal the most. It sounds alot like the Mind Bender and the Voodoo labs pedal...i like the features cost, casing, and controls better than anything else i tried so far.
I have a lot of thinking and playing to do but i think the Dunlop is the winner so far...
a few more to try will keep you posted