If there are frets in it, a lot of the preference for woods is down to how it looks.
I think on a maple body rosewood will look nice. But as you say, what finish you use can makes all the difference.
For me I would pick which piece of wood I like best out of the two you have. I think all maple could work nicely.
I think on a maple body rosewood will look nice. But as you say, what finish you use can makes all the difference.
For me I would pick which piece of wood I like best out of the two you have. I think all maple could work nicely.