• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Growl Effect

Yeah actives are a good idea with the J bridge pickup. I just got a PJ body and was toying with the idea of having one knob (volume), a 2-position toggle switch (P or J but not both), and a preamp for the J only (with trim pots in the control cavity for bass, treble, and to level its output to the passive P).
 
Fenders especially are kind of wimpy in a band mix, IMO. Keep the fender for recording and save up for a Warwick Thumb BO and never worry about growl again.

:hyper::bassist::D

But, if you don't like the Thumb style/feel (many don't), you can always get a Corvette (more affordable) or Streamer (more expensive) with a wenge neck/fretboard, bubinga/ovongkol body, and JJ pickups with active MEC electronics. Growl for days!

They come up for sale fairly often on the Warwick forum...

edit: I can't speak to Fenders as I don't play em, my comments reflect my Warwick experience only.
 
Yeah actives are a good idea with the J bridge pickup. I just got a PJ body and was toying with the idea of having one knob (volume), a 2-position toggle switch (P or J but not both), and a preamp for the J only (with trim pots in the control cavity for bass, treble, and to level its output to the passive P).

Preamp for Bridge J only, huh? I would have an active passive bypass and allow the neck p pickup to go through the preamp for room control, and then you can bypass it for tone
 
You're gonna get your butt kicked. A p-bass can be more in the front than any modern bass.

+ 1. I own a Warwick Thumb BO, it has been years and that thing keeps getting better and better with aging...huge monster growl machine, hard to hide in a mix but I agree that oversimplification pointing at a particular brand is not useful and, most of all, true...
I currently do not own a p-bass (mostly because of the crisis that is biting Europe), but based on my past experiences I can honestly say that some Fenders are almost (almost..) as growly, in a different manner, but for sure they can punch trough a mix with efficacy.
Even if I love the thumb timbre and I think it can cope almost all sounds (try the neck PU solo'd for a killer p-bass like grunt or the bridge Pu favored for outrageous burp!), in some occasions a p-bass can put on the table even more desirable features, like a familiar and traditional tone, and a substantial, supportive tone.