TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
"A lot of people are bringing up Led Zeppelin - did any of them know about Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, T-Model, Junior Kimbrough?"I'm 24. I feel like I'm on a reddit thread in an echo-chamber. Yeah it does skew older but I can't believe people believe in GC ceo nonsense. While I hate social media and phones to an extent. You cannot deny that they allow way more info to be free. A lot of people are bringing up Led Zeppelin - did any of them know about Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, T-Model, Junior Kimbrough? I bet a decent amount never heard of the guys that LZ "borrow" from... I would honestly argue more people know about Muddy Waters today because of the internet than 30 years ago...
It's just an opinion"A lot of people are bringing up Led Zeppelin - did any of them know about Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, T-Model, Junior Kimbrough?"
Or Jeff Beck, or even Buddy Guy.
This always bugs me when someone says Page (or Clapton) was the greatest player ever. I ask them if they know any of the above.
They rarely do.
It is -It's just an opinion
What makes me happy is when people cross the streams:Even today you still see a lot of younger people involved in the old time and bluegrass scenes. There are also a ton of younger people and players into things like Gypsy jazz and pre-bop swing music although that's a little less US-centric.
In my band when they had pit they would use the EB in the pit. Same during basketball or when sitting on the stands. Usually the EB player would learn Sousa or Euphonium to help at least in my band if they wanted to march. Maybe carrying a giant generator and amp in a cart ain't bad.... They only use the upright bass for the concert band. The marching band only uses an electric bass. Actually the concert band uses the upright bass and 2 electric basses.
Gen Jones-er?Music has always been hard. The dropout rate has always been high, Today, there are lots of other things kids can do that are easier, so there may be more dropouts, but I'd guess it's not all that different. Anyone who is really into music will persist.
And yes, your 70's Fender is unlikely to be a prized or valuable possession when the boomers are gone, and the nostalgia factor goes with us/them.
I just found out I'm maybe not a boomer, but a Generation Jones-er.
The only hope is for a resurgence of the Pete Townsend "Art Smash" encore... I wish I could find find the interview where Pete talks about playing encores in the Who's later years. "When we first started coming back on stage to do encores, my feelings were ***? Then I remembered that in the old days, it was never a question, since we destroyed the instruments..."A non-musician friend recently told me he read an article essentially stating that ācasual collectorsā like me were propping up the music instrument industry, and that without regular people having collections of dozens or hundreds of guitars/basses, the industry would collapse.
The real issue is not the number of new musicians who stick with it or not. The real issue is the longevity of an instrument. Guitars made in the 50ās and 60ās still work just as good as new ones (with some tlc). Of course value on those vintage instruments has grown to the point many people donāt play them daily. But if you look at how many new instruments are made each year, it far outweighs the number of new musicians who started playing that year.
Itās kinda a pyramid issue - itās never going to get better. More and more people need to become collectors just to absorb the number of instruments in circulation. Guitar shop inventory will climb higher and higher as the unsold instruments pile up.
āLuckilyā, there seems to be WAY fewer basses made each year - closer to a more sustainable amount - though much fewer bass players out there, and again, I bet many of us have become collectors. Gone are the days where you own just one bass or one guitar.
It will get worse in the future. Thereās no way to avoid it. Keep pumping new instruments in to circulation, eventually the whole system will collapse. There may be a day when our collections become worthless - like a collection of accordions - and no one wants to pay more than $100 for a 1960ās Jazz bass. If Iām still around, and in a financial position to act, I will buy a massive warehouse, and go around purchasing hundreds of thousands of vintage instruments to fill it with!(but even spends $50M on a massive collection I could never even play each for 1 second, it would be a drop in the bucket for the instrument market.)
a 12 yr old girl once asked me if I liked the Arctic Monkeys (2000s English rock band) and that she collected their vinyl. She wore a scarf, bangles on her wrists, bangs in her eyes. Rockers still exists.I'm a music teacher. I perform music with 11-12 year olds regularly.
the cool part is that "making music" is such a human thing, my students totally get it and have a real musical experience. it's in there. many of them have gone on to be really fine musicians - one of my best cellists from years ago is now playing bass in a rock band. she's fantastic.
culturally, it's deteriorated. for generations up until the 2010 or so "social media era," the music a teenager identified with was a huge part of their social ecosystem. The jocks like the gangster rap, the punks had their thing, some kids had a mild preference for certain pop, whatever.
when I visit the high school in my district, I don't feel like this is the case at all anymore.
I've had private students who were very skilled players that I could not get them "into" anything. They would learn it, perhaps comment that this one chord or song or whatever was nice, and move on. no deeper connection.
I remember taking my bass lessons in 2003-4 with my teacher Joe. He was so interested when I came to him telling him all about les claypool and the cool instrument he used and how I learned x song and i had blisters on my thumb from playing like him... and so on. (joe obviously already knew this but was happy that i found something 'for myself')
I've been a full time music educator since 2016 - I don't think I've ever had a student come to me with a real enthusiasm for a particular style.
what I have seen is them get exited of the 30 second soundbite they've heard on tiktok. A number of years ago the intro to roundabout went viral among the kids, I remember teaching that to a few guitar students. but they only wanted to know that little viral bit, not the song, or anything about yes, etc etc.
there's something new happening and seeing young people enjoy making music literally every day keeps me optimistic that it's just new, not worse.
but the days of taking home an album or cd, hearing it over and over again where you know every moment, that is definitely over.
as far as GC goes, we must understand they are also competing with better and better inexpensive instruments from elsewhere, and just lots of other options in the market in general.
There are some acceptably playable basses these days for $100. Smashable and easily replaceable. Its crazy.The only hope is for a resurgence of the Pete Townsend "Art Smash" encore... I wish I could find find the interview where Pete talks about playing encores in the Who's later years. "When we first started coming back on stage to do encores, my feelings were ***? Then I remembered that in the old days, it was never a question, since we destroyed the instruments..."
OK playa's, get with it...
a 12 yr old girl once asked me if I liked the Arctic Monkeys (2000s English rock band) and that she collected their vinyl. She wore a scarf, bangles on her wrists, bangs in her eyes. Rockers still exists.
This isnāt exactly late breaking news.I'm not sure if this was posted as this story seems to be about a week.
Guitar Center CEO seems to fear lost sales as many young people just don't stick with music. One out of ten, he claims, stay with it after a year, nine drop out.
Is social media destroying the youth's attention span to concentrate?
The young might not want our vintage gear we spent so much on.
Hark! The dawn of AI music is upon us unless we can create more musicians!!
![]()
āFor every 10 people who start playing guitar, a year later, one person is playing, and nine are notā: Guitar Center is looking to create more ālong-termā musicians ā hereās how
Guitar Center is amping up new ways to nurture the futures of budding musicians within its stores.guitar.com
that GC article and many hear are talking about your generation and younger.I'm 24. I feel like I'm on a reddit thread in an echo-chamber. Yeah it does skew older but I can't believe people believe in GC ceo nonsense. While I hate social media and phones to an extent. You cannot deny that they allow way more info to be free. A lot of people are bringing up Led Zeppelin - did any of them know about Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, T-Model, Junior Kimbrough? I bet a decent amount never heard of the guys that LZ "borrow" from... I would honestly argue more people know about Muddy Waters today because of the internet than 30 years ago...
"A lot of people are bringing up Led Zeppelin - did any of them know about Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, T-Model, Junior Kimbrough?"
Or Jeff Beck, or even Buddy Guy.
This always bugs me when someone says Page (or Clapton) was the greatest player ever. I ask them if they know any of the above.
They rarely do.
The definition of Boomers is a very wide swath in age, and some have pointed out that it's too wide - many of us were born way after the end of WW2 - so far after it that we were born after the Korean War as well, and we don't share all that much in common with the older boomers. "Generation Jones" has been proposed to deal with that - from 1955 to 1964 birth dates.Gen Jones-er?