TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
...every time, I played like that...I got hollered at.
Of course, it was in a New Country band.
![]()
His playing is awesome but even he can't make a P sound good!

It's funny, I've come full circle on P-basses. These days I really like a well played P-bass as another flavor of good, and have really started to appreciate a slapped P-bass again too.Another couple who can't make a P bass sound good!
Sorry man but the P will always have that 'cheap starter bass' tone to me. It just doesn't work for my ears, and I don't think the Precision is ever more exposed than when someone tries to ply something technical or that needs a lot of articulation on it.
I also was never a fan of the P-bass (although hearing John Wetton was eye-opening). But now I love it.It's funny, I've come full circle on P-basses. These days I really like a well played P-bass as another flavor of good, and have really started to appreciate a slapped P-bass again too.
I hear you. There is something crude and ham-fisted about the way a P sounds. But that quality is what now draws me to them. I like the drunken-bull-in-a-china-shop sound a P can get. Of course I'm not a traditionalist, I like a 5-string P with bright rounds and the tone all the way up.Sorry man but the P will always have that 'cheap starter bass' tone to me.
I cut my teeth on a battered '64 P-bass. Bought it in 1975 from a friend's older brother's friend for $200. I also bought a '64 Bassman amp from the same guy.It's funny, I've come full circle on P-basses. These days I really like a well played P-bass as another flavor of good, and have really started to appreciate a slapped P-bass again too.
OK...hadda do it. Louis Johnson >