I would insist on the new body along with the full refund. Don't give in from the start.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
that is correct.Unbelievable...
If I remember correctly, that blue bass is the special ADE you ordered, right? If so, I would get a full refund and place a silver Jazz bass pickup outline, like the one mentioned by @Ric5 before to keep it all original.
I even told him the story about my daughter helping deaign it. If he didn’t have the skills he should’ve told me right then and there.
It's a real shame. Think about the silver outline to have the bass unchanged since it holds such sentimental value.
I hope it ends up well, good luck.
I hope it ends up well, good luck.
Then take them to small claims court if they still refuse to make it right. A mild threat to share your experience and the shop's name and other detail with every musician you can might also encourage them to do the right thing.
Last edited:
Well, the bass isn't completely ruined, but its aesthetics and resale value sure are. I don't know what you spent on the work, but I'd ask the luthier to either refund the amount you paid him OR the cost of an equivalent replacement body, whichever is more.
buldog5151bass
Kibble, milkbones, and P Basses. And redheads.
I would ask him to refund the actual cost of that exact body from Fender, ask for that exact amount of money, and the hourly cost of a professional to assemble the instrument (and you get to keep that body as well). I would also ask for his explanation of not only what happened, but why he did not tell you. Absent some explanation of which I cannot imagine, he is incompetent and/or unethical.
Absent complete satisfaction, I would go to small claims court with both instruments, and as good pictures of a proper P/J as you can find. If you can find any articles on proper pickup placement, bring that as well. A judge is unlikely to be knowledgeable on instruments. It's gonna take some time. Until then, play the instrument. You may decide to keep any proceeds and live with it
Absent complete satisfaction, I would go to small claims court with both instruments, and as good pictures of a proper P/J as you can find. If you can find any articles on proper pickup placement, bring that as well. A judge is unlikely to be knowledgeable on instruments. It's gonna take some time. Until then, play the instrument. You may decide to keep any proceeds and live with it
I'd confront him with the f*** up he's done to your bass and let him come up with a solution.
I work in a field where people spend that kind of money on a hobby and when we have to deal with
a poorly executed job like this we go a great way to make sure the customer leaves happy.
I work in a field where people spend that kind of money on a hobby and when we have to deal with
a poorly executed job like this we go a great way to make sure the customer leaves happy.
Not sure how you knew I drove a Fender, but pick me some winning lottery tickets, while you're at it...
I feel for you, no doubt it would have me fuming. I would bring it back and ask them if this looks right to him. He may feel guilty enough that he makes it right. If he can't come up with a solution I would have a thought or two ready, non that would incude him working on it.
Any thread that describes a tech as reputable, respected, or trusted sends up red flags. Major botch job. Good luck seeking remediation.
Riis
Riis
As a small business owner, and someone that has worked for other small businesses for most of my life, I will say that we all know that there is a chance that it will happen eventually. Sometimes you have to take a bath on a job in order to ensure that a customer ends up happy, or at the very least won't end up telling everyone in town about how you screwed up a job. We all make mistakes, the important part is owning up to them and doing the right thing. These kind of images going around the internet could ruin that business.
In my opinion there is no way that when confronted about this job that the person that did it can deny that there is a problem. It's very simple to mark the center line of whatever you are working on and use that as a guide. Thats carpentry 101.
And for the guy thats saying that all that matters is the sound, I say that the sound should be a given considering that good parts are used. The most important part is doing a pro job with good fit and finish. If this were my instrument I would not be able to play it in it's present state no matter how good it sounds because in my mind it would be tainted.
