You're gonna get a lot of this, but...
Go with what sounds better to you. It really doesn't matter who says which is better - everyone will have their opinions. Play through both with YOUR instrument, and then form your opinion. A/B them blindfolded, if you can.
The worst thing you can do is follow popular opinion blindly. Sure, you'll be proud of your new _______ at first, but once the nameplate novelty wears off, you've still got to live with that decision. Or sell it at a loss.
We've all done it, myself included.