• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Help! Loud drummer, feedback issues, not hearing vocals....

Will doing all these things take away the feeling of the "rock n roll"?

No, it won't - it will rock even more, especially for the audience, IMO!
But, being in a band with an incredibly loud drummer myself, I also understand that it's only fair that he plays as he feels right; it's his style and he's good at it. Putting his playing on a leash, I wouldn't want that.

For us, it works to monitor vocals with ear plugs; my vocal mic goes into an interface (Focusrite Scarlett), where it is amplified, then routed to each of us; we're using cable-bound body pack headphone preamps (Fischer Amps Body Pack). The interface provides enough gain, and the body packs have a built-in limiter.

Works perfect; I can hear my vocals clearly and dynamic enough to recognise when I'm not close enough at the mic; and even our drummer who was sceptical at first mentioned he's very surprised, works superb for him, too.

Side benefit: The (normal not customised) ear-plugs also dampen the sound by quite some dB, which really helps me. Otherwise, I'd be deaf already :D

Maybe it works for you, as well.
Anyway, much success and much fun - rock! \m/
 
No, it won't - it will rock even more, especially for the audience, IMO!
But, being in a band with an incredibly loud drummer myself, I also understand that it's only fair that he plays as he feels right; it's his style and he's good at it. Putting his playing on a leash, I wouldn't want that.

For us, it works to monitor vocals with ear plugs; my vocal mic goes into an interface (Focusrite Scarlett), where it is amplified, then routed to each of us; we're using cable-bound body pack headphone preamps (Fischer Amps Body Pack). The interface provides enough gain, and the body packs have a built-in limiter.

Works perfect; I can hear my vocals clearly and dynamic enough to recognise when I'm not close enough at the mic; and even our drummer who was sceptical at first mentioned he's very surprised, works superb for him, too.

Side benefit: The (normal not customised) ear-plugs also dampen the sound by quite some dB, which really helps me. Otherwise, I'd be deaf already :D

Maybe it works for you, as well.
Anyway, much success and much fun - rock! \m/
Thanks man, the other side of the problem is blasting the audience. All 5 bands were just too loud last night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Schreiber
Thanks man, the other side of the problem is blasting the audience. All 5 bands were just too loud last night.
Did the INTENDED AUDIENCE think so? I used to do sound and there were always folks coming up to me thanking me for not assaulting them :wideyed: but the hearing damaged musicians and their burnt out ears "posses" would rather the normals get driven out of their clubs so I said **** it and joined them since I couldn't beat them LOL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Schreiber
Ya, it was overkill, the problem was how tight the space was and the shape of the bar. Most of the aggravation was the single speaker PA and the feedback that was happening. Feedback hurts. People still enjoyed the music, don't get me wrong. Got some complements from friends, but its not really their opinion that matters, I know enough to know good sound vs bad sound. And I got to hear the other 4 bands from the audience perspective, I got blasted and spent most of the night chatting outside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Schreiber
We play some fast loud music. I'd like to get to where I can hear the vocals, I think that's the greatest part of what were making. Do you think its ok for me to ask the drummer and guitarist to pull out the earplugs and see if we can bring it down to 1/4 volume and still rock out? Is this even possible?

I don't want to risk peoples hearing but this is getting a bit frustrating. I practice to our recorded tracks in my other practice space at LOUD full volume and the vocals are so good. But in our other practice space and at shows its absolute crap. Cant hear a damn thing.

Should we get a drum shield, lightest size drumsticks? Do moon gels really help much at all?

Will doing all these things take away the feeling of the "rock n roll"?

Honest help/feedback will be the most appreciated and if you have any clips of you or anyone else playing heavy rock without ear plugs in tight places and still sounding good I'd like to listen/watch. Plz no BS and fire the drummer comments, I like the guy.

Sorry but what makes the biggest impression on me is that you have a drummer and guitarist who should already be aware of the problem they have created without your telling them. The fact that you have to bring this to your attention means they don't care that they can't each each other or the vocalist or you. For them, music is all about them hearing themselves very loud, not collaborating with other people to make a cooperative product. For example, my guess is they have no idea when you or the vocalist are performing great or making lots of mistakes.
It may sound harsh but if the drummer and guitarist don't react very favorably very quickly to your suggestions (which are very reasonable by the way), they never will. At that point, it will be up to you to decide whether you want to deal with the extreme volume, and the fact that ultimately the guitarist and drummer don't care what you are playing.
 
Ya that's kinda what it feels like, although these guys do care about the music and are making good stuff. Its loud rock, and I want it to be more technical rock. The drummer doesn't sing, just the guitarist and myself. Guitarists voice is super high and cuts through much better than my deep voice. Its a great dynamic though, just hard for me to push through the mix in any way. My pa in my person practice space is pretty nice, a b-52 with 10's 600 watts. but the rentals spots just seems to feedback way more easily. and the rental spot is double the room size. strange imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Schreiber
Single speaker for vocals? That's when I also experienced feedback.
Solution was: Getting a second speaker, and a 31-band EQ to adapt to the room.

The second speaker allows for a better sound distribution - and with the EQ you tame the frequencies that are most prone to feedback, depending on the room, number of people inside etc..
Plus: No need to drive the vocals too hard ; as soon as you have proper monitoring (hearing yourself), then you are free to set the PA to a volume suitable for the audience alone; not for hearing yourself. And feedback shouldn't be an issue, especially with a (hyper)cardioid mic, like the one you mentioned - don't know the EV 96, just read it's a hypercardioid which should be fine.

Don't give up - it's good that you've recognised the problem and won't ignore it but improve your performance.
That's respectable, me thinks. Much success! \m/
 
The first part of problem solving is getting a clear and concise statement of the actual problem. Let me try:

Your drummer sucks and your guitarist sucks and they aren't going to change.

Hope that helps you find the best course of action.



...And by the way, if you need me to elaborate on how I arrived at that statement based on your OP and my experience I'd be happy to.
 
Last edited:
The first part of problem solving is getting a clear and concise statement of the actual problem. Let me try:

Your drummer sucks and your guitarist sucks and they aren't going to change.

Hope that helps you find the best course of action.



...And by the way, if you need me to elaborate on how I arrived at that statement based on your OP and my experience I'd be happy to.
They're talented, just not completely skilled
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Schreiber
They're talented, just not completely skilled


OK, sure. But the skills that they are not complete in are REQUIRED to function in a band setting.

I don't care if they can play like Yngwie Malmsteen and Neil Peart, If they can't communicate with other human beings all you are going to have is a constant headache. (Figuratively AND literally)

Being able to listen to others is a requirement of communication. These jackholes are too busy drowning everyone out for no practical reason whatsoever. Whatever their priorities and motivations are, they are not band oriented.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Five String
OK, sure. But the skills that they are not complete in are REQUIRED to function in a band setting.

I don't care if they can play like Yngwie Malmsteen and Neil Peart, If they can't communicate with other human beings all you are going to have is a constant headache. (Figuratively AND literally)

Being able to listen to others is a requirement of communication. These jackholes are too busy drowning everyone out for no practical reason whatsoever. Whatever their priorities and motivations are, they are not band oriented.
Only the future will tell. And if you read the op I'm looking for only constructive criticism, suckism doesn't really help. We'll figure it out.