• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass hoffmeister concertos

sibass89 said:
...Haydn wrote a concerto for bass and everything but the exposition is lost.

That would be something really cool. i don't know about you guys, but honestly, something I dislike about Double Bass, it's that the composers that wrote for it, are not that good. It would be great to see great composer's names on a recital poster, because in a violin recital you see that in the program names like Bach, Mozart, Bartok & other great masters, but in a double bass recital you see names like Eccles, Capuzzi, Bottesini and Proto, and people say things like "Who the hell are they" . I also dislike that the fact is that you can see those names only like in a transcription. I am not saying that works like the Bottesini Concerto is a bad work. but, COME ON!!! It could never be compared to the Dvorak cello concerto, or the Tchaicovsky Violin concerto, or even tha Bartok viola concerto.
A Mozart "Concerto for bass", A Schubert "Sonata for bass", some Stravinski pieces for Double bass, or something like a "Concerto for Double Bass and Orchestra" by Franz Joseph Haydn... it would be like a dream... That's, of course, my opinion...
 
But let's be reazonable: I think that you could never compare a Haydn Cello Concerto with a double bass Concerto like Capuzzi, Pichel, Cimador or even Dragonetti (in A Major). These are all good pieces, but it's not the same stuff!!
 
Beto said:
But let's be reazonable: I think that you could never compare a Haydn Cello Concerto with a double bass Concerto like Capuzzi, Pichel, Cimador or even Dragonetti (in A Major). These are all good pieces, but it's not the same stuff!!

maybe you should write a concerto for double bass.

that way our recital posters could say "Capuzzi, Bottesini, Beto..."
 
Beto, depending on how advanced a player you are, why don't you purchase Levinson's transcription of the Haydn C Major cello concerto and work on that. One of his doctoral students just played it at his recital and it was great. Great transcription and great piece.
 
For those who have never heard the Hoffmeister concerto in C there is a clip on Thierry Barbe's website with the man himself playing with string quartet accompaniment. (opens in realplayer) Personally I think that it's more interesting than the usual Vanhal/Dittersdorf stuff (not quite sure why though, probably because I havent heard it 20 times before) but it's still no Haydn concerto......oh well.

Link Removed
 
Beto said:
That would be something really cool. i don't know about you guys, but honestly, something I dislike about Double Bass, it's that the composers that wrote for it, are not that good. It would be great to see great composer's names on a recital poster, because in a violin recital you see that in the program names like Bach, Mozart, Bartok & other great masters, but in a double bass recital you see names like Eccles, Capuzzi, Bottesini and Proto, and people say things like "Who the hell are they" . I also dislike that the fact is that you can see those names only like in a transcription. I am not saying that works like the Bottesini Concerto is a bad work. but, COME ON!!! It could never be compared to the Dvorak cello concerto, or the Tchaicovsky Violin concerto, or even tha Bartok viola concerto.
A Mozart "Concerto for bass", A Schubert "Sonata for bass", some Stravinski pieces for Double bass, or something like a "Concerto for Double Bass and Orchestra" by Franz Joseph Haydn... it would be like a dream... That's, of course, my opinion...

Well...Mozart did write a piece for the double bass. Per Questa Bella Mano, an aria for bass, double bass, and orchestra which is, of course, wonderful. There's also some big names that wrote solo pieces for the double bass during the 20th/21st century including Henze, Xenakis, Schuller, Rouse, Hindemith, Rautavaara, Menotti, Persichetti, Wolff, and most recently Harbison.
 
p.nemeth said:
Well...Mozart did write a piece for the double bass. Per Questa Bella Mano, an aria for bass, double bass, and orchestra which is, of course, wonderful. There's also some big names that wrote solo pieces for the double bass during the 20th/21st century including Henze, Xenakis, Schuller, Rouse, Hindemith, Rautavaara, Menotti, Persichetti, Wolff, and most recently Harbison.

Well...that is good example, but you're not going to compare it with the last three violin Concertos by Mozart.