Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
How high can you tune a 5 string set
- Thread starter GC34
- Start date
Um, is it just curiosity or do you really wish to have a baritone guitar with bass scale, string spacing and gauges? An octave up is four times the tension. I'd be surprised if you can get more than, say, a minor sixth increase in pitch out of the lowest strings before they break. Probably even less. But hey, I might be wrong. "Treble" strings, as you imply, have thinner cores and usually more tension at standard tuning pitches, ergo already quite close to breaking point.
If you tune *any* bass strings an octave too high you’ll wreck the neck, the strings, or both.
Also, why? Get thinner strings if you want higher tuning.
Also, why? Get thinner strings if you want higher tuning.
I want to know what note each strings breaks at. I want to know how high I can go without breaking
Why don't you try and find out for yourself, and report back with your findings?
Just be careful, though, so you don't get hurt doing it. A protective shield for your face might not be a bad idea.
I don,t have a regular bass. Only a 3/4 upright. I managed to get the low E up to C on it and the A up to E flat and D up to F# and G up to A. None of them snapped.
According to this old thread, which you posted in by the way (a long-lasting interest you have there
), you may be right: 162 pounds to break a .105 is about a whole octave up from its intended E1 at 34":How much tension to break an "E" string????
According to this old thread, which you posted in by the way (a long-lasting interest you have there
How much tension to break an "E" string????
That's quite a lot. I was thinking it would break around C# or D. Still close to an octave. It might reach there if it's a new string.
It's going to be different with every instrument, based on the strength of the neck, how well the bridge is secured, & how well the machine-heads are constructed.
add:
almost forgot, the sheering strength of the metal in the core of the string will be important as well, as the string will also likely break if the neck is strong enough, the machine-heads are well-built, & the bridge is secured well
add:
almost forgot, the sheering strength of the metal in the core of the string will be important as well, as the string will also likely break if the neck is strong enough, the machine-heads are well-built, & the bridge is secured well
Last edited:
Doubt. Managed to snap a string from overtuning early on in my idiocy. Barely got a few semitones up.
If you try this just make sure to video record it and have your next of kin share the video here.
Well go for it then. You’ll pull your neck out of alignment first. Good way to ruin a bass neck if you can succeed in getting an octave up.
Wear eye protection and take video I like watching people destroy their stuff for my entertainment.
He will not manage to break the neck as the strings will broke before.
