• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How learning to read bass clef has transformed my playing

I’ve been playing (electric) bass for over forty years and am primarily a cover band person, so typically have had little need to read notated scores. But I decided to set out to learn to read bass clef fluently, to see where it would take my playing. Having now spent a couple of years slugging it out reading difficult bass transcriptions (along with a metronome - absolutely essential, or it’s a waste of time), my awareness and execution of timing on sixteenth notes and syncopations is so much more refined than before, with innumerable benefits to my playing.

To be fair, I had learned to read treble clef as a little kid when I had a few years of classical guitar lessons, but hadn’t used that skill in decades. Even with whatever benefit that had, reading bass clef, with all the different rhythmic combinations, is an entirely different beast. I think there are enough online resources out there to get anyone who’s an experienced player started on reading, but a few lessons could be helpful if you’re not self-motivated enough to want to undertake something like this.

I spent many hours with the Jamerson (Standing in the Shadows) and other transcriptions, as well as various exercise books (many without tabs, which is actually better for this) along with a metronome (Tempo app), and this has tuned my ear and rhythmic recognition so that I am now hearing recordings and playing them back with an entirely new level of accuracy. This accuracy can be the make or break between playing your part in a way that either pops or fizzles, say on the main motif of a funky song.

I also find that my ability to invent my own creative funky and rhythmically interesting bass lines is much improved. I think this is in part because all the different possible rhythmic combinations are now burned into my brain, and come out naturally as part of my musical thought process.

Many of the Jamerson transcriptions in that book book are in keys like Eb, Ab, Db, Gb and learning to fight through sight reading these will improve your overall fretboard knowledge, as well as your comfort level playing songs in keys like that. Again, these are things that will benefit you even when you are learning a song strictly from a recording.

I could go on and on, but all the time I’ve invested in this has totally re-invigorated my joy of playing and learning. I’m in my 60’s, so you’re never too old to improve. Hopefully I’ve inspired someone else to do likewise. Thanks for reading!
 
my awareness and execution of timing on sixteenth notes and syncopations is so much more refined than before, with innumerable benefits to my playing.

this has tuned my ear and rhythmic recognition so that I am now hearing recordings and playing them back with an entirely new level of accuracy. This accuracy can be the make or break between playing your part in a way that either pops or fizzles, say on the main motif of a funky song.

I also find that my ability to invent my own creative funky and rhythmically interesting bass lines is much improved. I think this is in part because all the different possible rhythmic combinations are now burned into my brain, and come out naturally as part of my musical thought process.
More refined, more accurate more creative.
Oh what a winning hand…

Well done @NeckPickup :bassist:
 
I could go on and on, but all the time I’ve invested in this has totally re-invigorated my joy of playing and learning. I’m in my 60’s, so you’re never too old to improve. Hopefully I’ve inspired someone else to do likewise.

Your post is just what the doctor ordered for me to be able to take my playing to the next level. I took up the bass for the first time in 2009 at age 52 and started playing actively in church 10 yrs ago (2013) and have done okay so far, but I feel I've been stagnating for the last few years, looking for ways to further improve my skills.

I think you've just provided the inspiration I needed to motivate myself to do something that's been on the back of my mind for the last little while, ie learning to read standard notation better so I can speak the musical language more fluently.

THANK YOU! :thumbsup:
 
It’s the language we use to communicate music to other musicians.

I also grew up on treble clef (violin) and later learned bass clef. I’ve said before I do it love the chicken scratch marks on train tracks notation but nevertheless, it is a valuable skill and you’ll never “lose a gig” for knowing how to read. In my own dumb experience I think knowing treble is valuable as a bassin’ guy because there are a skajillion guitarists who can read and write treble but don’t have the chops with lower clef, the notes are the same. Technology has made things easier but if a guitarist hands me scrawl in treble clef it’s nice to know what they mean.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeckPickup
Thanks to all for your responses. I wanted to add one thing, which is that what motivated me to get started with all this was an interview I read with Gary Lunn, who is a superb Nashville session bassist (check out some of his work, there isn’t a style he isn’t great at). Anyway, he made the point that playing along with recordings will only get you so far, and that to develop absolute confidence as a timekeeper, you need to practice with just a metronome. He’s so right, as the most tangible improvements I’ve seen in my playing have to do with timing.
 
my awareness and execution of timing on sixteenth notes and syncopations is so much more refined than before, with innumerable benefits to my playing ...I am now hearing recordings and playing them back with an entirely new level of accuracy...I also find that my ability to invent my own creative funky and rhythmically interesting bass lines is much improved.

This mirrors my experience precisely!
Literacy improves rhythmic awareness, no question about it.


develop absolute confidence as a timekeeper, you need to practice with just a metronome.
another +1
 
On the flip side: was trying to learn to play piano and got pretty dang good at reading treble clef! A bonus to be able to get proficient at reading both!
Been reading bass clef for decades starting in grade school orch dbl bass, which I dropped in 8th grade = WORST decision I ever made. ☮

FWIW: only use metronome/drum machine for slap.
Back when using a metronome as a lad, used to feel the clicks as 2 & 4. A "trick" my Union guitar player bass teacher taught.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NeckPickup
Good on ya - whenever there is a post on TB with someone just starting out on bass or looking to go to the next level, my advice always is learn to read, it opens up so many doors! I'm not the worlds fastest reader but I do so every day, and it significantly broadens what I can work on. The funny thing is like you, I started out on treble clef and actually have a hard time switching between the two. Some of the material I work on "Bach Shapes - Jon De Lucia) ocassionally includes passages in treble clef, and I play with a guitarist where I sometimes want to learn the melody of a song, but I find reading treble to be difficult.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NeckPickup
My take on Berlin’s stance is that he is saying if you practice with a metronome too soon (when you are still making mistakes and using poor form/technique) that you’ll just enforce those bad habits, albeit in time. Practice the knowledge, form/technique without the added metronome factor first, then add it in.
Exactly. Very well said.

I found the same with using a tuner for intonation on a Fretless bass and for thumb position on a Double Bass. First learn a smooth relaxed technique, then refine it with a tuner.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Slade N