I have been a Jazz Bass guy forever. I didn't think I needed a P bass until I got one.
My point is YES you need a P LOL. Personally I wouldn't get a new American P bass. They are way overpriced for what you get IMO. I would look at CV Squier P Bass before a new American Fender.
^ This.
I did just that. CV Precision (FR with Tort guard - HA!).
Set of Chromes.
Wowza.

