• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How many use a pick?

Do you play with a pick, or fingers, or thumb pick, or combo?

  • Fingers

  • Flat pick

  • Thumb pick

  • Sometimes pick, sometimes fingers, depends on song


Results are only viewable after voting.
Toughest part using fingers is when I need to go beyond the E and A strings, and keeping other strings from ringing out.

FWIW I have found that I have slowly been able to adapt to muting with my fretting hand fingers. When playing guitar I use a combination of that and pick hand muting (heavy on pick hand). Due to hand placement when playing bass fingerstyle I simply had to adapt to get the sound right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jt62
FWIW I have found that I have slowly been able to adapt to muting with my fretting hand fingers. When playing guitar I use a combination of that and pick hand muting (heavy on pick hand). Due to hand placement when playing bass fingerstyle I simply had to adapt to get the sound right.

Dead on. I agree. Palm muting which I use all the time on guitar is natural for me, using my fretting hand, sometimes, but that seems easier on guitar as I already have fingers on most strings I'm playing from a chord shape (I play rhythm 99% of the time) and can just flatten them to mute. All part of the journey I suppose, correct fretting technique as well as finger plucking technique on bass, as it's different from guitar, are what I need to work on most.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kjp360
I use whatever I feel like - it might be what the song calls for if I'm playing with other people, or it might be what I feel like when I pick up a particular bass. This is one of my favorite personal performances of mine, because it's on someone else's album - we briefly played in a band together in the '80s and he contacted me out of the blue to play on a track - it's pick on a Rickenbacker 4001, one of my all-time favorite combinations! - I love how he processed the bass after the fact, especially the first break!

 
I use 2, sometimes 3 fingers at times, and a pick (not a thumb pic) other times. It depends on the song. Also, I've developed some issues with the tendons in my hand that sometimes pop up when I play with my fingers, so I use the pick to bypass the pain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmt
So how many use a pick? Or even a thumb pick like Jack Blades?!?! Or just fingers? Or a combination?

I started out playing with a pick, because I was a guitarist. moved to fingers when I moved to bass. I always preferred the tone of fingerstyle, now I switch if the song calls for it. I can do both very well, but prefer finger style. i tend to shy from pick playing because I think there's a stigma of pick playing is for electric guitar. it might be incorrect but that was the mindset when i started out. and I work a lot on my right hand technique, so It's become a very versatile style for me. plus I never think uh oh, he plays with his fingers unless his technique is sloppy. same with pick players.but I haven't seen a picker, that made me want to switch back. Just a product of my generation.
 
Last edited:
Almost exclusively a pick. One of the upsides of not being anything like a professional bassist is that I can stick to what I like and what I think I make sound good rather than having to learn a bunch of styles to suit a gig. I can play with my fingers and I do it once in a while, but IMO I sound a lot better using a pick. It's just what my hands are best oriented towards.
 
i play exclusively finger style in both of my bands because the style calls for it (funk, soul, jazz). i do know how to play with a pick and if i were playing a style that called for that sound, i would use one without hesitation. there are some tunes i would love to use a felt pick on, but basically the life on a felt pick with roundwounds is about 5 minutes. i've used felt picks in the studio before to get that somewhere-in-between thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robscott
Right now a hand injury prevents me from playing fingerstyle or holding a pick, so thumbpick to the rescue. Contrary to expectations, I've been able to conjure up a useable tone for jazz and swing with a bit of EQ adustment. I still need to improve my technique - upstrokes can be problematic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 43ManSquamish
Like a lot of people here, I use what ever the song calls for. In my last band, we played country, so I used my fingers for most songs. For the rock band I played in previous to that, about half the songs I used a pick, the rest I used fingers.