• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is this normal?

I recently picked up a Carvin LB70 that sounded pretty good even though the (round wound) strings were obviously shot. I couldn't wait to hear the bass with some decent strings. All I had on hand were some Cleartones that a friend gave me for Christmas, so even though I tend to prefer flat wounds, I figured "let's give them a try".

Well, the E string was totally dead, but the rest sounded monster on that bass- great output, pretty good tone. Went to GC and showed (yes, they made me bring the bass in) the dead string and they offered to exchange them, but I paid the difference to get the same La Bella Deep Talkers that I have on my p bass. Now, the bass stills sounds good, but the output dropped seriously. I don't remember this happening with my p bass- but, on the other hand, I was pretty new at the time.

Also, the action is a good bit higher. I thought the flats must be pulling harder on the neck, but when I measured the neck adjustment it was good, so how did putting flats on raise the action? Could the higher action be the reason for the lower output? The set-up was spot on when I bought it (according to the original paperwork I got with the bass). Is this normal when switching to flats?

I would have tried lowering the bridge already, but it needs a smaller allen wrench than I have (.050"). Thanks in advance for any help!
 
But if the tension was the reason, wouldn't the measurement of the neck relief changed?

Also, how would that account for the lower output?

Update- found an old set of round wounds and the sound/output is back, so I guess flats just put out that much less?
 
But if the tension was the reason, wouldn't the measurement of the neck relief changed?

Also, how would that account for the lower output?

Update- found an old set of round wounds and the sound/output is back, so I guess flats just put out that much less?
YES!!

Play a bass with rounds unplugged.
You can hear it.

Play a bass with flats unplugged.
It's hard to hear.
Plus most flats tend to have higher string tension than rounds.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts