• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass It's impossible to sing and play the bass...

#9
TheorboPlayer said:
Hi,
I'm wondering if someone take already the challenge to transcribe that song so "clever" :-)
Of course singing and playng DB or theorbo is my main source of worries. Any idea how to improve ?
Best regards
Lino
Click to expand...

How to improve? Just like you improve with anything else, practice, practice, practice. :D
 
#14
Your original question had to do with singing while playing the bass. None of the responses seem to address that point, so I'll give it a stab.

I also find it very difficult to sing while playing bass. I've been taking singing lessons for a couple of years now, and feel better about it, but still struggle. I'm a true amateur, so take this for what it's worth.

I think the two main difficulties (for me at least) are
- Singing 3rds & 5ths while playing roots. (With a guitar or piano, you're playing chords, so the note you're trying to sing usually is embedded in what you're playing)

- Singing off the beat while laying down a steady rhythm

For me, putting the difficulties in words helps, because I can then work specifically on the problem. There are many exercises out there to help you ID and sing 3rds, flatted 3rds, 5ths, etc., and with training and practice anyone can do it.

When singing, I usually can't play complicated rhythm patterns, but I usually can find a pattern appropriate to the song that allows me to sing and play bass at the same time. Likewise, I will look for bass line tones (notes) that will help key me into the melody tone I am trying to sing.

I don't know if this helps or not, but it's how I approach singing while playing bass. I'm still taking lessons, and I still hate my voice when I hear it recorded or on the PA. But I try to quantify exactly what I don't like about my voice, so I can work on it. (Right now it's depth and articulation, & my teacher's been giving me pointers to work on)

There are plenty of bass players out there who also are good singers that probably have better tips than me
 
#15
Like I tell my students that ask the same question.

You have to be very comfortable with either singing or playing to pull something like that off. You can't be struggling with both singing and bass playing and expect things to work out fine. One thing has to already be part of you, especially on complicated songs.

Look at thew Geddy Lee story. Rush went in and recorded their first album and if you know how tracking is done in a studio, for the most part you don't sing and play at the same time.
They completed the album and when they went into rehearsal for the tour he found he couldn't sing and play what he had done in the studio at the same time. They postponed the tour and Geddy took like a month of solid practicing before he was comfortable doing both things at once.

Good luck!
 
#17
Who da Ville said:
Your original question had to do with singing while playing the bass. None of the responses seem to address that point, so I'll give it a stab.

I also find it very difficult to sing while playing bass. I've been taking singing lessons for a couple of years now, and feel better about it, but still struggle. I'm a true amateur, so take this for what it's worth.

I think the two main difficulties (for me at least) are
- Singing 3rds & 5ths while playing roots. (With a guitar or piano, you're playing chords, so the note you're trying to sing usually is embedded in what you're playing)

- Singing off the beat while laying down a steady rhythm

For me, putting the difficulties in words helps, because I can then work specifically on the problem. There are many exercises out there to help you ID and sing 3rds, flatted 3rds, 5ths, etc., and with training and practice anyone can do it.

When singing, I usually can't play complicated rhythm patterns, but I usually can find a pattern appropriate to the song that allows me to sing and play bass at the same time. Likewise, I will look for bass line tones (notes) that will help key me into the melody tone I am trying to sing.

I don't know if this helps or not, but it's how I approach singing while playing bass. I'm still taking lessons, and I still hate my voice when I hear it recorded or on the PA. But I try to quantify exactly what I don't like about my voice, so I can work on it. (Right now it's depth and articulation, & my teacher's been giving me pointers to work on)

There are plenty of bass players out there who also are good singers that probably have better tips than me
Click to expand...

these are all good tips but the OP was talking about this song. It's Impossible to Play the Bass and Sing
 
#19
I've done !
Not a transcription of the bass line but just the cords progression. It is something like :
|F7|Em7 A7|Am7b5|D7| etc
I can send the whole grid if someone is interested on it.
I've choosen this song as exemple because I believe it is false "easy" song.
Try it, you discover that it is very difficoult to maintain the groove, the lightness of the song (if you sing and play of course).
What Mr Leonhart do is quite sophisticated and I like it very much
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back