• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

iTunes

If you upload music in AAC format, it's not "protected" like when you use the music store. The A[pple]A[udio]C[odec] is just that, a codec. A lot of people think that ALL AAC files are "protected" and cannot be converted. This is only true of the iTunes music store downloads.

Kibuddy gave you the right instructions, that's how I do it. There's no burning CD's or importing involved with that, you just have to delete the AAC file when you're done.
 
Drake Kennedy said:
^ Someone has a grudge against Apple :smug: :p

Like I said before, the AAC format isn't "handcuffware" unless you buy from iTunes, which I don't. AAC lets you have smaller files than MP3 so you can fit more songs on your iPod. Or more songs wherever.

Not against Apple, against any proprietary and/or patented file format.

Proprietary formats are bad, this should help explain:

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]
 
AAC is a licensable format administered by the MPEG-LA group. Like MP3, someone does own the patent to the CODEC. Almost all audio, video and still image formats are covered by patents. That's the way it is, otherwise, what's the incentive to come up with newer and better ways of doing stuff.
 
Drake Kennedy said:
Like I said before, the AAC format isn't "handcuffware" unless you buy from iTunes......

Yep. I assumed that the OP was trying to convert some files he bought from iTunes.

I just read a nice article in Information Week about Apple and their proprietary file format for iTunes. This is going to catch up with them eventually. Every time a user downloads a "new" copy of iTunes, they are pulling those handcuffs a little bit tighter. Each of the last few iTunes updates have included tighter security restrictions.

-Mike
 
MJ5150 said:
Yep. I assumed that the OP was trying to convert some files he bought from iTunes.

I just read a nice article in Information Week about Apple and their proprietary file format for iTunes. This is going to catch up with them eventually. Every time a user downloads a "new" copy of iTunes, they are pulling those handcuffs a little bit tighter. Each of the last few iTunes updates have included tighter security restrictions.

-Mike

You mean like MS' proprietary protected music for their music player?

Anyone who spends almost the full price for a CD for 128kbps from AAPL or MSFT should already know they're getting an inferior product. No liner notes, lyrics, case art and lower audio fidelity. I'd rather spend $13 instead of $10 and get all I mentioned plus the ability to rip the CD into whatever compressed format I feel like. Of course this excludes Sony/BMI CDs with that wonderful Windows rootkit software included free with CD purchase as well as other CD copy protection schemes.