• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

"J" pickups discussion and comparisons - PART II

Thinking about ordering a Fender American Pro II Jazz w/the Generation 4 Noiseless pickups. It would plug into a Noble tube preamp --> amp/interface. Any love for these? I've had Fralins in another Jazz bass and liked them a lot. My main bass activity these days is recording basslines for hire. It's important for the signal to be silent when not playing. And of course, it had better sound good too!

I have Am Pro II Jazz and it's been great. But since I've put Lollars in it - it's the whole new level. It's everything I want it to be, especially neck pickup can sound anything between warm and straight filthy. I can't recommend these pickups enough.
 
I have Am Pro II Jazz and it's been great. But since I've put Lollars in it - it's the whole new level. It's everything I want it to be, especially neck pickup can sound anything between warm and straight filthy. I can't recommend these pickups enough.

I've heard recordings w/Lollars and love them ... but they are not made in a split/stacked coil / noiseless configuration. I do a lot of recording and can't have the 60 cycle hum potentially lurking. How do you get around that?
 
I do not have any problems with hum. And I do play a lot with configs other than both pickups open. Mainly 100/80, 100/0 and 0/100 with tone off (Jaco).

But I am not gigging / recording pro and you can have other opinion. They are not truly noiseless by any means, but imo they are reasonably quiet. I do not experience any sort of hum that could bother me at all.
 
I do not have any problems with hum. And I do play a lot with configs other than both pickups open. Mainly 100/80, 100/0 and 0/100 with tone off (Jaco).

But I am not gigging / recording pro and you can have other opinion. They are not truly noiseless by any means, but imo they are reasonably quiet. I do not experience any sort of hum that could bother me at all.

My producer hears static and other noise that I cannot hear. Clean signal = not getting fired! :)
 
G&L JB5 strings do not align with the pickup pole pieces and the low B sounded different from the rest, it annoys me.

Change to DCBs and the low B finally sounded equal to the rest of the strings.

C49736C9-8517-4ECA-9E40-1B4CEE7A787F.jpeg
 
I just installed a Delano JVMC FE in my jaguar shortscale in the bridge position (paired with a PMVC FE in the neck). I feel the JMVC lacks some high end. Even on full vol, full tone, I can't get it to be edgy and a bit more direct in the treble frequencies. Even if I cut the mids and up the treble on my amps. I am running it on V V T, 250k pots, passive wiring. I'm wondering if a 500k tone pot might brighten things up. Then again, maybe I have the wronrg understanding of what these pickups can deliver in terms of brightness? Any users here who could advise? Go for all 500k pots for these high output pickups? I guess its worth a try.
 
I just installed a Delano JVMC FE in my jaguar shortscale in the bridge position (paired with a PMVC FE in the neck). I feel the JMVC lacks some high end. Even on full vol, full tone, I can't get it to be edgy and a bit more direct in the treble frequencies. Even if I cut the mids and up the treble on my amps. I am running it on V V T, 250k pots, passive wiring. I'm wondering if a 500k tone pot might brighten things up. Then again, maybe I have the wronrg understanding of what these pickups can deliver in terms of brightness? Any users here who could advise? Go for all 500k pots for these high output pickups? I guess its worth a try.
Two things -- I have Delano JC 4 HE/M2 pickups in my main player, and I've never had any problems getting all the high end I want out of them; and I'd go with 500K pots just on general principles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: j-stylez
@BlueTalon how do you like the Delano JC 4 HE/M2 vs the fender super 55 split coil pickups?
I love them both! The Fender Super 55 is, in my opinion, the best sounding pickup Fender has ever made. I would say that the character of the Super 55 and the JC4 HE/M2 are similar. But I'm kinda shifting away from pickups with exposed pole pieces. Not enough to replace pickups in basses that have pickups I like, but any new basses are getting closed top pickups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pbass888
Possibly the B string sounded different for other reasons than pole alignment.
Now you cant tell if theyre aligned or not :)
A lot of closed-top J pickups have blades in them rather than pole pieces, which means the strings are aligned no matter where they cross the top of the pickup.
 
I love them both! The Fender Super 55 is, in my opinion, the best sounding pickup Fender has ever made. I would say that the character of the Super 55 and the JC4 HE/M2 are similar. But I'm kinda shifting away from pickups with exposed pole pieces. Not enough to replace pickups in basses that have pickups I like, but any new basses are getting closed top pickups.


Thankyou . I was looking at the Delanos but went with the super 55. I love them and agree about being the best Fender pickups !
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueTalon
Does anyone know if the current EMG J set sounds the same (or at least the design has not changed apart from solderless change) compared to the 80s-era ones?

From what I can tell, they sound the same, but I haven't used EMG J pickups for 30 years, until just recently, so my memory might be fuzzy at best.

I dropped a set into a parts Jazz that I've been working on. Used it for a gig over the weekend, and they sounds fantastic.