Hi Bruce,
I find what you wrote to be a fair statement however, I was trying to fit the two into the subject of the thread. I agree that in most instances they were completely different but I still maintain they were the top of their prospective genres in their era.
All of this is completely different from what James Jamerson did - he was known as a high-volume session player - and was not known as a composer/arranger - although of course his lines added hugely to a lot of great tunes.
On this point I do maintain that Jamerson was the most prolific Composer/Arranger of his time from the prospective of the bass. He MADE some of those tunes great with his basslines. I think the people at Motown were extreemly wise to let him go full steam. No arranger at that time could write for him. Later everybody tried to copy him. Same thing with Jaco.
Jaco's main intrance onto the scene was as a bassist. The composer/arranger Jaco was later in his all too short career. Sad...
BL
PS one more thing that Jaco and Jamerson share. They both had problems with substances and were sick (mentally) towards the end. In Jmaerson's case he apparently felt neglected for all his contributions to Motown and to music in general. They both died prematurely.
I find what you wrote to be a fair statement however, I was trying to fit the two into the subject of the thread. I agree that in most instances they were completely different but I still maintain they were the top of their prospective genres in their era.
All of this is completely different from what James Jamerson did - he was known as a high-volume session player - and was not known as a composer/arranger - although of course his lines added hugely to a lot of great tunes.
On this point I do maintain that Jamerson was the most prolific Composer/Arranger of his time from the prospective of the bass. He MADE some of those tunes great with his basslines. I think the people at Motown were extreemly wise to let him go full steam. No arranger at that time could write for him. Later everybody tried to copy him. Same thing with Jaco.
Jaco's main intrance onto the scene was as a bassist. The composer/arranger Jaco was later in his all too short career. Sad...
BL
PS one more thing that Jaco and Jamerson share. They both had problems with substances and were sick (mentally) towards the end. In Jmaerson's case he apparently felt neglected for all his contributions to Motown and to music in general. They both died prematurely.