Jazz Bass Tone; Which strings to use?

I've not used either of these strings before but in general they seem pretty similar.

 

These are on a stingray and the Fenders are supposedly the same as D'addario XL. Here's an idea of how they sound like

 

The outer wrap is nickel-plated-steel on both. But the NYXL features a couple of enhanced features.

From D'Addario website:

NYXL Bass features our high carbon NY Steel core wrapped with our reformulated nickel-plated steel. This new construction delivers deep, powerful lows, focused punch, and accentuated harmonics. Designed for all playing styles, NYXL Bass provides more dynamic range and sustain than any other bass string.
​

The XL Nickels remain the standard because of their availability and affordability. Many people around here feel the NYXL's enhanced features are NOT worth the extra money.

 

Personally, I like stainless steel rounds on a Jazz bass. I think they bring out the natural tonal characteristics of them best.

 

Any roundwound string will do...

 

As far as I understand it, the OP is simply asking for advice which of the two sets already in possession would be better to put on the Jazz bass - D'A XL Nickels or NYXL Nickels?

 

Jazz Bass Tone; Which strings to use?
Any.

 

Get the EXL170-5 cause it's way cheaper, unless you could have some kind of special deal with the NYXL 45-130.

Sound wise, both are almost similar (though some would say the NYXL sound better). But, the NYXL will be easier on fingers due to lighter tensions.

 

I’ve tried D’Addario NYXLs on three different basses I own. And I came away very unimpressed.

I don’t care for NYXLs.

D’Addario nickles are just fine depending on the bass.

 

I have always started with the EXLs on a new bass as they are pretty neutral and consistent. A reliable standard to see what the bass sounds like.
However, I usually end up with Sunbeams - a little more mellow and less "zing" than the D-As

 

I’ve tried D’Addario NYXLs on three different basses I own. And I came away very unimpressed.

I don’t care for NYXLs.

D’Addario nickles are just fine depending on the bass.

 

D'Addario EXL nickels have been my main go to string for almost 20 years now. They are good all around string that suit any style of music.
A couple weeks ago I've started using the NYXLs and I have mixed feelings about them. They are definitely brighter and maybe louder. They sound more like stainless than nickels. I need to give them more play time and see if they just need to break in a little more. Supposedly they have less tension than the XLs but I don't see too much of a difference.

 

I did not see an option for neither. Why are you limiting yourself to those 2 only?

 

I agree...What I do is try to select strings that balance out or off set the bass's natural sound. For a darker scooped Jazz, Dunlop Nickel Super Brights once broken in are fantastic and super growly. If you need more warmth or low/mids, I use GHS pressuewounds. Add Roundcore Boomer's an a nice middle ground and those are my 3 goto sets for Jazz Bass's.

 

I think as far as rounds go, Dunlop Super Bright Nickels are the best.

 

on my cheap P bass it makes no difference.. they are cheap enough to try.. each.. I prefer my strings coated like black beauties and flat dead..

 

No he isn't. You're wrong.

 

If you already have the NYXLs, why wouldn’t you just put them on and see how you like the sound? If you like them, great! If you don’t like them, then you can try something else.