I think the John East just might be better since it offers a true passive mod. For now I'm going to divert my attention to my other "project" which is my new '20 Ultra PJ-Bass.
I'll be adding a 3rd pup closer to the neck.
I've made a temporary rig using an inverted "U" shape jig out of wood to mount the test pup upside down to face the strings from the top. The bass was laying flat on the bench and I could move the pup freely wherever I wanted. I used a passive Seymour Duncan J Bridge pickup I had laying around closer to the neck. I wired it in parallel with the existing bridge pickup and OMG!
It was one of those moments when you hear an angelic choir sound coming from heaven!
I think I just may have found the most awesome bass sound ever!!! LoL. I gotta have it!
The initial results were a big boost in bottom end but with extreme clarity. No muddy boomy sound but a huge increase in bass tone. The results were awesome in both Passive AND Active modes!! I gotta have it!
The Fender preamp didn't put up a fuss with the added PU at all. No noise, phase issues whatsoever.
The sound that came out is very rich, full and OMG AMAZING! I MUST HAVE IT! (Did I mention that before???)
I'll add it's own volume control and MAYBE a DPDT switch to add it to either the OE Neck or OE Bridge pickups.
But the initial test with the new pickup wired in parallel with the OE bridge sounded amazing first try.
The added pickup did not seem to effect the Blend/Balance pot either.
The independent volume control will be it's ON/OFF as well or I could add another balance/blend pot to balance between either P or J pups.
Just adding in the 3rd pickup closer to the neck will make me smile with it in the mix without any other control other than volume. Anything added after will be "optional"?
So on to routing we go......