• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Lead vocalist and bassist, how impressive is it?

I do backing vocals and underneath speeches during in many of the chorus sections in my band . It took my some time to coordinate playing and "singing". The vocalist in my bands always wants me to sing an entire song but im affraid to mess up lol. I think ill practice to be able to do it
 
I think "Walking" style basslines are easy enough to sing over, depending on how consistent they are, but I can sing over "Groove" stuff when I know the bassline inside out on some occasions.

I think singing over bass fills is the most impressive thing. Nothing like seeing someone sing even really simple stuff over a blindingly fast bass fill.
 
I think its impressive depending on what genre of music.... straight 8 or 16th notes are easy and not very impressive to me... but i think a reggae bass player who plays ROOTS style reggae and sings is amazing.... not many reggae bass players that lead sing too. Haile Maskel is one of those bass players - worth checking out and seeing live!
 
Gail Ann Dorsey - great bassplayer and singer. When she's touring with David Bowie, they play Under Pressure and she plays the bass and sings Freddie Mercury's vocals. Her solo albums are brilliant as well. Personally, I can't sing worth a s*** anyway(except for hardcore punk-type screaming), but the kind of music I was playing back when I was singing and playing bass was pretty much extremely simple lyrics and basslines. Other than that, I get totally lost trying to do both.
 
I played for years in the background, doing harmony on some songs and maybe 3-4 lead on simple stuff.

The band I am in now is vocally challenged so I started practicing songs that I could sing and play on.

I found that there was a certain level of bassline complexity that I cannot go beyond, but a little imagination and lots of practice makes the 25 songs that I do lead on come out fine.

Just practice practice.
 
Gail Ann Dorsey - great bassplayer and singer. When she's touring with David Bowie, they play Under Pressure and she plays the bass and sings Freddie Mercury's vocals. Her solo albums are brilliant as well. Personally, I can't sing worth a s*** anyway(except for hardcore punk-type screaming), but the kind of music I was playing back when I was singing and playing bass was pretty much extremely simple lyrics and basslines. Other than that, I get totally lost trying to do both.
Gail Ann Dorsey was touring as Gwen Staffani's bass player last year. I don't know if she's still with GS but there's some cool stuff on YouTube about her. She's funky~!

Highly enjoyable:
 
Functional MRI's show that some very different parts of the brain are involved, so those of you who find it easy have got great wiring up there.

This isn't to call you out on this... because I have no idea about anything medical... but do you have a paper or link you could forward to me about this... I find it very interesting.

My Two Pennies: I was the singer in my last band, but I didn't play bass. I just sang. The band I am in now occasionally asks me to sing and play at the same time... but I find it very difficult. Some songs, like U2's Vertigo, I just can't sing on. The bass line is not hard... but something about it just makes it hard for me to sing. However, I can sing and play Rush's Tom Sawyer in my sleep. I need to get a vocal coach or something.
 
I saw it on scienceblogs.com and on David Sukuzi's website.

Also, all your words come from Broca's and Wernecke's (whether you're singing or talking) - that's from Oliver Sacks book "The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat" - but I don't recall which chapter (where he details, as well, the area of the brain where melodies are apparently organized - in a chapter, IIRC, about a woman with a severe chronic form of earworm). Also, David Pinkard's books on brain and language talk about the different known functional areas of the brain (I think he may be the one who summarizes aspects of rhythm recognition).

There are couple of bloggers on www.scienceblogs.com who are musicians and like to post about all this, although I haven't been over there for awhile.

Here's a basic link I could find on the one larger project using Invalid Link Removed I'll bet the two researchers mentioned would answer your emails if you were interested in more about their studies.

And here's a Invalid Link Removed that shows that we musicians are special. I knew that.

This doesn't mean that people are born musicians, necessarily (doesn't rule it out, either) but it's clear, especially from some of the studies that people's brains respond to music, and musician's brains develop special responses and capacities.

Indeed, one of the very first fMRI studies of music was about learning to tap one's fingers rhythmically, and which part of the brain eventually became hardwired to do it (and how long that took in various people).
 
P.S. - the Japanese article has a bunch of online references about music and the brain, as well as their own research showing how the age at which one learns music seems to change the amount of brain space reserved for it or something (although their definition of "learning music", I did not read).

Anyway - way more stuff in that article than in the older stuff I mentioned. Way more.
 
I'm lucky I guess in that I've never had a problem singing lead or backup and playing bass at the same time. I've been doing it for a very long time and I really enjoy it....a lot.


George
 
Hm for me it was just of a thing I was never really required to do till I was pushed into it. By then I already really wanted to any ways and just something I worked out. A lot of beatles and who stuff really helped me, given I was really familiar with the bass and lyrics from most of their songs. Ramones was also very fun to take a whip at.