• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Motivation: Why do we do it?

I was recently talking about this with a friend. While his drive was more ego driven, mine is much deeper.

I whole heartedly believe God designed me specifically to play music. While I have many other interests and have other talents, nothing even comes close to the feeling I get when I’m playing bass. Now at 39, regardless if I ever land a touring gig with Lincoln Brewster or Keith Urban, lead worship at my church, jam locally, or play along with 100+ tunes a week, I will play to the absolute best of my abilities and give any and all musical ventures my ALL.

Plus, I think we all feel the same way here... low notes go boom boom feel good.
I have never heard it put more succinctly and perfectly as you just did right here... these are the very things friends would tell me when I would get down on myself about the what and why of playing music in general. Including the boom boom part. ;)
God bless you, Element; you made my day:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Element Zero
I believe you’re on the mark IMO on everything but the porn analogy; these onlookers for the most part would probably trade their passive role for a more participatory one...:D
In my day, porn involved lighting people, sound people, multiple camera people, fluffers, and other hangers on. It's problematic for many men to perform in such a situation.

These days any joker with a phone/hd cam can be a pornographer. Even that can be daunting to many.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nashrakh
I do what I want. End of story.
tenor.gif


Sorry, couldn't resist.
 
I play because it's part of who I am, that feeling when the band is grooving, people are having fun listening or dancing, hard to get better than that.

I play gigs for free. I get paid for practice, schlepping equipment, carrying it around and setting it up, plugging it all in and setting the PA and lights, than after the gig doing all of those steps in reverse.

And I like to make the $$ for all that. My wife and I agreed long ago that money for my music "toys" would come from money I made playing. It works for us and that makes the money important to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bassanomaly
When I was young, being a musician defined who I was. It gave me purpose and direction. Having kids swept the knee on that self identity and I wound up putting my bass down for quite a while.

Having come back to music again, it is no longer a self identity but simply a form of artistic expression. It amuses me how much better at playing bass I am now as a hobbyist, but I think I appreciate it more for what it is.

I play in a dad rock originals band at 48 years old, so obviously not in it for the money. :roflmao: I play because I enjoy creating music, the camaraderie, and the rush of performing.
 
I was recently talking about this with a friend. While his drive was more ego driven, mine is much deeper.

I whole heartedly believe God designed me specifically to play music. While I have many other interests and have other talents, nothing even comes close to the feeling I get when I’m playing bass. Now at 39, regardless if I ever land a touring gig with Lincoln Brewster or Keith Urban, lead worship at my church, jam locally, or play along with 100+ tunes a week, I will play to the absolute best of my abilities and give any and all musical ventures my ALL.

Plus, I think we all feel the same way here... low notes go boom boom feel good.

100%
 
  • Like
Reactions: Element Zero
Are any of you in the position of doing it strictly for a paycheck and not for the love of it? Sadly, that's where I've found myself in recent years. The passion faded a long time ago, and even though I still occasionally play gigs, they're only for the purpose of making some supplemental income. I often dread the process and can't wait for it to be over. I never touch my bass unless I need to prepare for a gig.

I know it's not the healthiest approach, and I know I'll get some responses of "why don't you quit if you don't like it?" But for now, I need the cash, and music is something I'm familiar with and good at.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bruiser Stone
Are any of you in the position of doing it strictly for a paycheck and not for the love of it? Sadly, that's where I've found myself in recent years. The passion faded a long time ago, and even though I still occasionally play gigs, they're only for the purpose of making some supplemental income. I often dread the process and can't wait for it to be over. I never touch my bass unless I need to prepare for a gig.

I know it's not the healthiest approach, and I know I'll get some responses of "why don't you quit if you don't like it?" But for now, I need the cash, and music is something I'm familiar with and good at.

When did it transform from passion to a service?
 
One time I was driving with my daughter and I was listening to some Tejano music. My daughter asked why I was listening to music that I couldn’t understand.
“I understand it perfectly,” I told her.
“You speak Spanish?” She asked me.
“Not at all” I said. “I speak music. I don’t have to know the words to know what they are trying to say.”

That’s the magic of music, the universal language.
 
Most players here have been paid to play. There's never anything wrong with receiving compensation for our hard work. But is that the only reason we play?
At the end of the day, I do it because I love it. There is little (if anything) that gives me the sense of satisfaction that playing bass in a band gives me. It doesn't pay enough for me to do if I didn't love it.

That being said...

I usually refuse to play anything for free. 99.9% of the time, I will insist on being paid for my time and effort. For me, it's just a matter of principle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bunk McNulty
I was recently talking about this with a friend. While his drive was more ego driven, mine is much deeper.

I whole heartedly believe God designed me specifically to play music. While I have many other interests and have other talents, nothing even comes close to the feeling I get when I’m playing bass. Now at 39, regardless if I ever land a touring gig with Lincoln Brewster or Keith Urban, lead worship at my church, jam locally, or play along with 100+ tunes a week, I will play to the absolute best of my abilities and give any and all musical ventures my ALL.
And you'll still not make any real money :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Element Zero
Most players here have been paid to play. There's never anything wrong with receiving compensation for our hard work. But is that the only reason we play?

Saturday night, a friend of mine had a spot at a songwriters showcase & he wanted a stripped down version of his band to accompany him. Not a paying gig. Just a cool little 3-piece deal designed to highlight his excellent songwriting. I played fretless and people really enjoyed the night. It was cool.

Then this morning, I arrived at 7am to soundcheck at my church... two services. Got home at 1pm. Also not a monetary gig. Interesting thing about this was, I played lead guitar, which means I spent a lot of the week/weekend practicing, since I had a lot of parts to learn & it's a little more outside my comfort zone.

That means this weekend, with practice, drive time, and the actual gigs, I probably spent 10-15 hours of my time, all without financial renumeration.

Other weeks, I just sit and play alone at home, for hours at a time.

So I have to ask myself, "why do I do it?" Love of music? Devotion to my church or even my songwriter friend? Am I an attention whore? A sucker for punishment? Do I just have the music in me & need to get it out? Is it the best excuse I can find to justify buying gear? Or maybe, it's just fun. Who knows?

As a musician, why do you do what you do? What's your motivation for all the stuff that goes into playing bass?
I need some side cash and playing earns me a bit of that.

As I tell people, I play out for the love need of money. I play in (home) for the love of music.
 
Last edited: