I have read quite a few people are having very similar issues with that compressor. I am thinking that it might be a problem with opamp latch-up. Some opamps will latch with their output to the top or bottom rail if there is signal on the inputs before the circuit fully powers up.
I was testing some opamps that have been praised for superb audio quality a few months ago and had two different types of opamps latch-up when the power was applied. One of them would reset after several seconds and start working properly, but the other needed to have the power removed from the circuit… it would sometimes power up without a problem, but it was hit or miss. Some opamps that stay in a latched state for an extended period of time can be permanently damaged.
If that problem reappears with your compressor, remove the power plug from it for a few seconds while all of the other pedals are powered. That may reset the latching condition and the comp won’t have that power-up ‘thump’ from the other pedals to drive it into a latching state.
The other thing to try is contact MXR for service. I would think that with all of these issues they must be seeing, that they have remedied the problem and would make good on a warranty a couple months expired.
-Frank