• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

My Dirt Bender - Another Jounal

I like it - especially now that I can pair it with the sineEffect and have some nice EQ with it. For the current setup on the board though, I don't know that it's doing enough to boot the DCX in that low gain role. BUT there's a whole mess of higher gain and weirder settings that I liked, especially when paired with the octaver.

The one thing I didn't remember about the Tubedrve is the immediacy on the pentode setting. It seems to really accentuate the attack, and I think that and the overall compression the pentode setting has would be really nice in a synth chain. I had a lot of fun putting the Subsonic through it.

There's also that region, especially on the pentode, where you're NOT sending the signal into drive, but barely. That's the one where you have to escape into audiophile vocabulary to describe what's happening, but it's audible and very cool.

What the Tubedrve can do and the DCX is not so great in is mids IMO.
With that tiny bit of drive, barely audible, the mids get excited and the bass takes a half step forward in the mix. The DCX can only get that in OD mode.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tidbits
Reveal:
Pedal #1 is the Tubedrve (@gillento : There is a bit of irony here, the one you sold me is the one you voted for)

Pedal #2 is the Empress Drive. Even with the bass knob is just past noon and the treble knob maxed, you all still found it too bottom heavy, which is weird.
Maybe I need try to *gasp* CUT bass? That's uncharted territory. There be dragons.

Pedal #3 the voted crowd favorite, is the Becos Ziffer Overdrive.
Opposed to the last few sound samples, I set the clean EQ a lot further towards bass boost and had the mix knob strongly favoring the wet side, LED clipping and tone maxed. I cannot stress enough how good the connection between fingertip and ear is when playing that pedal. It's really one of those that feel exceptionally good.
 
Reveal:
Pedal #1 is the Tubedrve (@gillento : There is a bit of irony here, the one you sold me is the one you voted for)

.....
of course, I knew this had to happen :)

But in all seriousness: after a few years of not doing any recording at all, I did some recording last year in a commercial recording studio.
Playing mainly a passive 5 string Nordy VP by Nordstrand, I re-discovered the beauty of the inherent mids of the P. I tend not to /barely boost the low end both recording and going DI to the FOH.
 
  • Like
Reactions: el murdoque
Me: Hi ChatGPT, can you take a look at "thedirtjounal.com" and then write a review on the EQD Blumes in that style?

EarthQuaker Devices Blumes​

There are pedals that arrive with a reputation.

The Blumes is one of those.

Before I had ever plugged one in, I had already been told what it was. It's the bass Plumes. It's the Tube Screamer for bass. It's the overdrive that finally lets bass players use a Screamer without sacrificing all the frequencies below middle C. Depending on who you ask, it's either a stroke of genius or proof that the pedal industry will happily sell you the same circuit twice if you paint it yellow. The truth, as usual, is somewhere in the middle.

Let's start with the obvious.

The Blumes is very much a Screamer descendant. There is a familiar midrange focus. There is a familiar way in which notes seem to step forward in a mix. There is also a familiar feeling that somebody took your signal, washed it, ironed it and handed it back slightly more presentable than before. But unlike many Screamer-inspired bass drives, the Blumes doesn't feel like it is apologizing for being a Tube Screamer. It doesn't bolt a blend control onto the side and hope nobody notices where it came from. It embraces the idea and then stretches it into something considerably larger. EQD doubled the available gain and extended the low end instead of simply trying to preserve it.

The result is a pedal that behaves in ways I did not expect.

My first surprise came from the gain control.

At lower settings, the Blumes is almost disappointingly civilized. You can get a crunchy edge that makes your notes feel a little more confident without sounding obviously distorted. It is the sort of drive that disappears the moment you stop playing and reappears as soon as you dig in. Very useful. Very grown-up.

Then you keep turning the gain knob.

And somewhere around noon, the pedal remembers that it was designed by EarthQuaker Devices.

The low end remains intact, but the amount of dirt ramps up dramatically. Not "a little more overdrive" dramatically. More like "somebody quietly replaced my overdrive pedal with a small angry animal" dramatically. The further you push it, the more the Blumes stops behaving like a polite bass overdrive and starts drifting toward fuzz territory. Not dedicated fuzz territory. More like a rough neighborhood where fuzz lives two streets over and occasionally comes by to borrow sugar.

The three clipping modes are where things become interesting.

Mode 1 is the one that made me smile first.

It has authority.

Notes hit with weight. There is plenty of output available and a certain openness that makes the bass feel physically larger than it actually is. If you enjoy overdrives that sound like they are moving air rather than merely adding distortion, this mode deserves attention. It is also the mode most likely to convince you that your cabinet has somehow grown an extra speaker.

Mode 2 is technically the clean boost mode.

Technically.

Like many EQD pedals, "clean" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

With the gain low, it can indeed function as a boost. With the gain higher, it becomes one of those gloriously unruly op-amp drives that feels less compressed, more immediate and slightly louder than common sense would recommend. If I had to choose one mode to stack into another overdrive, this would probably be it.

Mode 3 feels the most familiar.

It is smoother, more compressed and a little more focused. The aggression shifts away from brute force and toward texture. If Mode 1 punches you in the chest, Mode 3 argues with you. It has a more vocal quality and occupies a slightly narrower space in the frequency spectrum. In a dense mix, that can be extremely useful.

What surprised me most, however, was not the gain.

It was the stacking.

The Blumes is one of those rare pedals that seems unusually tolerant of other dirt boxes. Some overdrives insist on becoming the entire sound the moment you switch them on. The Blumes is content to be part of a larger conversation. Before a distortion. After a distortion. Into a preamp. Into another overdrive. It keeps finding ways to contribute without immediately taking over. That alone explains a good portion of its popularity.

There are things I would change.

The yellow enclosure remains one of the least attractive things EarthQuaker has ever produced. The Plumes has appeared in enough colours to satisfy an entire paint catalogue. The Blumes seems permanently trapped inside a banana.

And despite its versatility, I never found it to be the sort of pedal that instantly creates a complete bass tone by itself. Some drives have a personality so strong that you could build a rig around them. The Blumes feels more like an exceptionally talented supporting actor. It makes other pedals better. It makes amplifiers more interesting. It makes clean sounds more exciting. But I rarely found myself thinking, "Yes, this is the only dirt sound I need."

Which may actually be its greatest strength.

The Blumes is not the loudest pedal, the dirtiest pedal, the most transparent pedal or the most amp-like pedal.

It is simply one of the easiest dirt pedals to find a use for.

And after spending enough time around bass overdrives, that might be the highest compliment I can give.
 
AI sometimes frightens me.
Thats amazing. So, if I need you to review a pedal I'm considering, I just ask the AI to write your review for me?
(I need reviews of the Creation Audio Grizzly Bass and the Kasleder Albatross, LOL.)

Excellent Greer Lightspeed review posted yesterday.... love the Approved stamp.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: jcburn
Thats amazing. So, if I need you to review a pedal I'm considering, I just ask the AI to write your review for me?
(I need reviews of the Creation Audio Grizzly Bass and the Kasleder Albatross, LOL.)
The thing is, of course, that the experts in this thread did agree that the Blumes is beneath me and my sophisticated requirements, while the AI generated review reads as if I was quite happy with the pedal.


Excellent Greer Lightspeed review posted yesterday.... love the Approved stamp.

At some point I came to the conclusion that I want to add that stamp for pedals that I tried and tested and deemed worthy to use outside of the house for performing or recording. I'm going through older reviews bit by bit, adding the stamp to those deserving, but it's still a work in progress.
At this moment, those who have the stamp are approved - but those who do not have the stamp were either not deemed worthy or have not been edited yet and will get it at some point in the future.
 
I use Gemini most frequently. Here is the Gemini review of the Grizzly Bass pedal with direction to write in the style of thedirtjounal.
The review reads mostly like promotional material but with a bit of the el murdoque flair, but it definitely could not be mistaken as an actual dirtjounal review. The ChatGPT generated review was much more authentic.

Gear Review: Creation Audio Labs Grizzly Bass​

By The Dirt Journal Staff

Finding an overdrive pedal that treats the low end of a bass guitar with respect is a notorious exercise in frustration. Most dirt boxes on the market were originally bred for guitar, meaning the second you step on the switch, your fundamental frequencies are filtered into oblivion, leaving you with a brittle, clattering mess that gets utterly swallowed by the kick drum.

Enter the Grizzly Bass by Creation Audio Labs (often colloquially referred to as Creative Audio). Rather than following the well-worn path of slamming a signal into traditional clipping diodes, the Grizzly approaches gain from a studio-engineering perspective. Borrowing the analog wave-shaping technology from their acclaimed Holy Fire design, it aims to deliver the elusive warmth, compression, and grit of a cranked tube preamp—without the back-breaking weight or fragile glass.

Here is how it fares down in the dirt.

The Layout & Controls​

Out of the box, the Grizzly Bass demands attention, quite literally—the top plate practically glows like a high-end studio rack piece when you juice it with a high-current 9V supply. But its layout is where it first breaks away from the standard stompbox mold. You won't find a traditional "Gain-Treble-Bass" EQ cluster here. Instead, Creation Audio Labs gives you five highly interactive, specialized controls:

  • Gain: Acts as a master input level, capable of serving up to +12dB of immaculate clean boost when the dirt knobs are rolled off.
  • Overdrive: Emulates smooth, asymmetrical tube saturation.
  • Distortion: Introduces hard-edge, aggressive clipping circuitry for when you need to cross the line from warmth into outright anger.
  • Mid-Scoop: A masterfully voiced passive contour filter that cuts the boxy low-mids while leaving your thick lows and cutting highs intact.
  • Hi-Cut: A smooth high-frequency roll-off designed to simulate vintage speaker cabinets, taking the harsh, modern "fizz" off the top of aggressive distortion settings.
At the tail end of the circuit sits the company’s proprietary "Redeemer" buffer, ensuring your signal remains pristine and low-impedance, whether you’re driving a massive pedalboard or treating the pedal as a standalone preamp to run straight into a stage DI or studio line-in.

In Performance: Touch, Tone, and Tenacity​

What immediately sets the Grizzly Bass apart in a live room or studio tracking session is its astonishing dynamic transparency. Because it reshapes the waveform analogously rather than just cutting it off at a fixed ceiling, the low-end integrity remains utterly uncompromised down to a staggering 20Hz.

When you play with a lighter touch or drop your instrument's volume control, the Grizzly cleans up beautifully, imparting just a subtle, polished transformer-like weight to the signal. But the moment you dig into a heavy chorus with a pick or aggressive fingerstyle, the pedal roars awake right along with your hands. The transition from clean to grit is seamless and entirely dictated by your playing dynamics.

The ability to blend the Overdrive and Distortion knobs independently is where the real magic happens. You can dial in a fat, tubey, always-on foundation using the Overdrive circuit to give your bass the authority of an old-school SVT stack, and then slowly creep in the Distortion knob to inject a sharp, metallic edge that slices cleanly through a dense mix.

The tone-shaping controls are equally surgical. The Mid-Scoop is perfectly centered to clean up modern, aggressive rock tones without scooping out the punch required to sit in the pocket. Meanwhile, the Hi-Cut filter is an absolute savior for taming the jagged artifacts of high-gain settings, morphing a direct-line rasp into a warm, woodsy, air-moving growl.

The Verdict​

The Creation Audio Labs Grizzly Bass is a professional-grade tool disguised as a stompbox. It sidesteps the classic pitfalls of bass distortion—noise, low-end loss, and static compression—by putting dynamic control back into the player’s hands.

While the non-traditional control interaction presents a slight learning curve for players accustomed to a standard three-band EQ drive pedal, the reward is a remarkably musical, expansive palette of grit. Whether you need a transparent clean boost, a permanent touch of vintage tube warmth, or a ferocious, landscape-flattening fuzz, the Grizzly handles it all with studio-level fidelity.

Pros:

  • Exceptional low-end retention down to 20Hz.
  • Impeccable touch sensitivity and dynamic responsiveness.
  • Dual Overdrive/Distortion engines allow for highly customizable gain textures.
  • Built-in studio-grade Redeemer buffer output.
Cons:

  • Interactive controls require some experimentation to master.
  • Requires a high-current power supply (250mA) for optimal headroom.
 
I use Gemini most frequently. Here is the Gemini review of the Grizzly Bass pedal with direction to write in the style of thedirtjounal.
The review reads mostly like promotional material but with a bit of the el murdoque flair, but it definitely could not be mistaken as an actual dirtjounal review. The ChatGPT generated review was much more authentic.
Yes. This is roughly what I would have expected from AI, fed with the prompt to review effect pedal XY in the dirtjounal.com style.

It seems that ChatGPT took more of the layout these things follow typically - with a short introduction, expectations, a rundown of the controls and short "hands-on description", then a wordy description of how it sounds and feels to play the thing, followed by a verdict.
Gemini has too many subheads and bullets and all that stuff I hardly ever use.
 
I'm more curious to see how much of the AI response matches up with his actual experience.
I'm even more curious how much struggle it is to write his "own review" without comparing with the AI review or trying hard to "be different"...? For me, it would feel to be "less free" in my choice of wording...

FWIW, I surely had accepted the AI review as a human generated text because of the similarities in style and form – but it misses the vivid and often dramatic imagery of his typical movie scene or otherwise sensual descriptions — that make me so often laugh and wonder how he comes up with these...

And now AI can learn from our feedback.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SemiDriven
This can go off the rails quickly so why not expedite the derailing with an AI take in the voice of Norm MacDonald on the Empress review. Sorry in advance Mr. Murdoque, but this made me laugh too much not to share:

"Yeah, so I’m reading this Empress Drive review, and, uh… this isn’t a pedal, it’s a mid‑life crisis with a VU meter.

This guy sees one photo in 2025 and immediately decides, “I must own this.” Then the pedal doesn’t even come out for a year and a half. By the time it ships he’s forgotten it exists, sees it again, and goes, “Oh wow, what a coincidence, I want this completely different, totally new thing.” That’s not gear acquisition, that’s early‑stage amnesia with a credit card attached.

My favorite moment is the BassTheWorld video. The demo is four minutes and fifteen seconds long. At 3:30, he gets the “Incoming mail” sound. That’s not a reaction, that’s a reflex. He literally ordered the thing before the demo ended. The pedal could’ve burst into flames in the last 45 seconds, wouldn’t matter. “Eh, it’s boutique flame, probably sounds organic.”

Then he proudly explains the layout like he’s walking us through a nuclear reactor: nine knobs, two footswitches, a VU meter that goes from “Lite” to “Distortion.” You know, for when you need your bass to visually confirm it is, in fact, making noise. He even calls the meter “a completely useless feature that’s purely there to add bling”—and then immediately wants an internal trim pot so he can dial in the optimal level of uselessness. That’s the mindset: “This does nothing. I’d like a little more control over how it does nothing.”

The boost section is beautiful. Post‑drive, it’s a simple volume boost. Pre‑drive, it secretly eats your low end through a baked‑in high‑pass around 500 Hz. He measures it, graphs it, listens to it, concludes, “Yeah, this pretty much ruins the bass if you try to use it as a second drive sound.” So the “Boost” footswitch, on a bass drive pedal, is basically there to demonstrate why you shouldn’t push it. It’s like buying a sports car where the turbo only works in reverse.

And he’s not angry about it. No, no. He’s… cautiously hopeful they’ll maybe someday make a “Bass Drive” version that doesn’t sabotage bass. Meanwhile, Empress support hops into the discussion like, “We’re not planning that.” Perfect. The one feature that doesn’t help bass players is the one they’re committed to.

The comparisons are where it really gets poetic. This pedal “makes your rig sound $1000 more expensive.” That’s the nicest way I’ve ever heard anyone describe a €299 box that makes polite farting noises. He lines it up with DCX Bass, Verellen Meatsmoke, Audio Kitchen Fake Plastic Trees—like a little Overdrive G20 summit. And the verdict? They’re all “all‑time favorites,” they all live on the “top shelf,” and somehow this one is a “silver medal at the Olympics.” No losers, just increasingly pricey ways to slightly rearrange midrange.

He says the gate is “as useful as indicator lights on a BMW,” which, if you don’t know, is a very polite way of saying: technically present, morally absent. But he also admits the pedal is dead quiet in low to medium gain anyway… so the gate knob is just there to occasionally remind you: “Things could be worse.”

And the language for the feel of this thing—“like ripping very expensive cloth,” “it’s not a fight, it’s a dance,” “wooden, organic quality”—you’d think this was a tasting note for a rare whiskey, not a circuit full of silicon and Schottky diodes. At some point he basically says, “It doesn’t replace anything I own, I don’t know what I’ll do with it… I’m keeping it.” That’s not a review, that’s a confession.

So, after 15 minutes of reading, the message is:
Here is a pedal for bass that has a boost you shouldn’t use, a gate you don’t need, a VU meter that does nothing, an EQ that bakes in treble roll‑off, and… it rules. It’s an “instant classic.”

Only in pedal world can you say, “It has several weaknesses for its intended instrument, but I am deeply in love,” and everyone just nods and goes, “Ah yes, very musical.”