• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD- Fender Player Precision Bass

Recently I bought a Fender Player Precision in sage green. I changed the original bridge for a Gotoh bridge that I had laying around. right off the bat this bass feels amazing to play and it is very light.
Before buying a p-bass (this is my first P) I was nervous because P basses are usually heavy and with big necks and I have small hands and Im used to jazz style necks, which my main bass has. I absolutely love playing this bass.
Sound-wise is another story. The bass sounds a bit thin or stringy to me, even after putting some flats in it, I feel it lacks that full sound that I was expecting from a P-Bass. I compared it with a friend's highway one precision and that one has a fuller and more powerful sound than the Player P with mine sounding more like a jazz bass in the neck pickup than it does to that Highway One.
Since its my first P I want to experiment with different pickups to hear their differences in a bass so I changed the orignals for a Seymour Duncan SPB-1 and I do not feel that there was a lot of change in the sounds, it became a tiny bit rounder but still lacks that punch. most likely Ill end up changing the pickups once more for some Fender PV63 to see if I get closer to that elusive vintage P-bass tone.
Anyways, what I love about the bass is the playability because even though the Highway One sounds way better to my ears, that one I can only play for a couple of songs before it starts bothering me whereas the Player P I can use for hours. Ill swap the pickups on the Player for other types of pickups just for fun but I do not think that Ill stay with this bass in the long run because I am not convinced on the sound. and it looks awesome.
 
Recently I bought a Fender Player Precision in sage green. I changed the original bridge for a Gotoh bridge that I had laying around...


...The bass sounds a bit thin or stringy to me, even after putting some flats in it, I feel it lacks that full sound that I was expecting from a P-Bass. I compared it with a friend's highway one precision and that one has a fuller and more powerful sound than the Player P with mine sounding more like a jazz bass in the neck pickup than it does to that Highway One...

I've been playing Fender P-basses since 1967.

IMHO, the high mass bridge does not help thicken the sound. I'd adjust the pick-up height to gain some output, but don't over do it.
I also have found that while flats are fun (I like Pyramid flats), good round wounds have more midrange and highs, which, once tamed, are going to give your tone more fullness and character as it sits in the mix.

Be careful of comparisons. Unless EVERYTHING is held constant, you will likely get a spurious (flawed) impression of what is really happening. Loudness (aka volume) is the biggest "difference maker." In the old days, when people thought a lot about buying hi-fi gear, salespeople knew that a tiny bump in volume due to speaker efficiency would sell a pair of speakers over another pair that were actually of superior quality.

Pickup height, action, and especially string type make a big difference, but so do the player and her technique.
 
I've been playing Fender P-basses since 1967.

IMHO, the high mass bridge does not help thicken the sound. I'd adjust the pick-up height to gain some output, but don't over do it.
I also have found that while flats are fun (I like Pyramid flats), good round wounds have more midrange and highs, which, once tamed, are going to give your tone more fullness and character as it sits in the mix.

Be careful of comparisons. Unless EVERYTHING is held constant, you will likely get a spurious (flawed) impression of what is really happening. Loudness (aka volume) is the biggest "difference maker." In the old days, when people thought a lot about buying hi-fi gear, salespeople knew that a tiny bump in volume due to speaker efficiency would sell a pair of speakers over another pair that were actually of superior quality.

Pickup height, action, and especially string type make a big difference, but so do the player and her technique.
I dont care much about volume because I know that you can always turn up the amp to get the desired level but its the tone itself that feels different, although I do get your point. Ill try and tinker with the pickup height to see how much difference it can make on the tone of my bass
 
Dimarzio Model P.

If possible make return, I highly recommend you Squier Classic Vibe 70P. Not the 2019 Indonesian made, find the one Made In China !!!! It stock pickup sound thick , punch and great output.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4sight
I agree the Player Series Precision basses feel great, I think the Player Series Jazz necks feel great too.
I think the all maple Player Series necks are the nicest feeling Fender Mexi necks they've ever made.
Not sure I understand the last bit of your original post, what does "not convinced on the sound" mean?
Do you want the sound of a Precision Bass or no?
If you do, then a P Bass pickup (there are so many choices) is the way to get the sound of a Precision Bass, nothing else sounds exactly like a split P pickup.
Why would you give up after trying just the SPB1?
I can see why you are not keen on the stock Fender pickup, I'm not a fan of the Fender Mexi P pickups either, they have never been very good.
There are sound samples you can listen to for many P Bass pickups to get you close to knowing your favorites.
YouTube and TalkBass searches will get you there.

My favorite aftermarket P pickups are the EMG GZR and the Dimarzio Model P but I've listened to Fender PV 63 sound samples and they sound very good too.
Don't give up on your Player Series Precision if you like the way the neck and body feel, everyone needs a good P Bass (bass with a split P pickup) in their stable.
 
I have a Player P-bass from 2018 with TI-Flats and it's very full sounding and present in the band mix. Personally, I don't care much for how it sounds soloed compared to my other basses. If this is your first P-bass your ear may not be accustomed to the mid-focused sound these tend to produce. Try it in a band setting and see what you think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twc1313
I have a Player P-bass from 2018 with TI-Flats and it's very full sounding and present in the band mix. Personally, I don't care much for how it sounds soloed compared to my other basses. If this is your first P-bass your ear may not be accustomed to the mid-focused sound these tend to produce. Try it in a band setting and see what you think.

Agreed. I'm not denying that your bass might not sound the best, you might have got a lemon or some have some setup issues. My Player P is one of the best sounding P basses I've owned and it kills with my one band. It's the only bass of ten or more basses I've played with that band that gets endless compliments and I am requested to bring it to gigs.

Give it a chance live, you won't be disappointed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SJan3 and bhendrix

Latest posts