• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD! Martin Keith Elfin Plus 5

Fuzzbass

P5 with overdrive
Gold Supporting Member
Dec 13, 2001
22,589
28,570
Maryland, between DC and Bawlmer
Ordered 3/14/14, arrived 7/17/14. A four-month turnaround is impressive for a high-end a-la-carte custom!

Specs:
Elfin Plus five string singlecut
Alder body (pearl red)
Maple neck and fretboard (light vintage tint)
Luminlay glow-in-the-dark side dots
34.5" scale - default
EVO fretwire - recommended upgrade
Pickups: both Nordstrand. Reverse P (neck), MM-style (bridge)
Aguilar OBP-1 preamp
Rotary controls: Master volume, Pickup blend, Passive tone, Treble, Bass
Push/pull switches: preamp bypass, series/parallel for MM pickup

My other 6 basses are 5-string P-bass variants so this bass is unique to me in a number of ways: singlecut, black hardware, 24 frets, angled headstock. Even though it's a singlecut I didn't want the boutique look so I went with painted body and non-figured maple board.

Q: Why this make and model?
A: I'm not normally a singlecut guy, but the elegant Elfin Plus design caught my eye. I also like the original Elfin (the nonplussed version, so to speak ;)), but the upsized Plus has Fender-style ergonomics and balance which is important to me. I first asked TalkBasser Marshall Perry about his Elfins, and then discussed options and pricing with Martin himself. It was super-easy to come up with a reasonably-priced build that included all the specs features I wanted, so I decided to pull the trigger as soon as my finances were order. I forgot to spend much time thinking about color, but I liked Marshall's Dakota Red bass so much that I went with red pearl (didn't want to be a complete copycat).

Q: How was the ordering experience?
A: I dealt with Martin directly throughout. Aside from the painting he's an army of one! Martin's a consummate professional: quick to respond to all inquiries. Progress on this order was so fast, I pinged him only once (unnecessarily) for an update. Any time there was news he delivered it promptly. I'm grateful for his attention to detail: he made sure every parameter was approved by me, even a few I'd overlooked. He also added a couple of perks to the order. Best example: the bass was originally supposed to have just one push/pull pot (series/parallel for the MM pickup), however Martin threw in a push/pull preamp bypass control for free because that way both EQ controls would use identical potentiometers, and therefore have the same feel and taper. As I said, details! Also, he was fastidious about shielding the instrument, and put some shaped wood blocks inside the P-bass pickup cover so it wouldn't feel hollow.

Q: Cut to the chase: what about the instrument itself?
A: It's getting late, so as quickly as I can: I'm thrilled. She has amazingly sexy curves, and looks. Pearl red is not CAR: it can look similar in photos (especially w/flash), but in person under ambient light it's muted/iridescent rather than metallic. I was happy to see (I'd forgotten!) that the fretboard and headstock face have a gloss finish, but the back of the neck is incredibly sexy satin... it almost feels like bare wood, which I love! This bass is not chambered, but even so it has a slimmed-down body and headstock, so it only weighs a little bit more than my chambered alder Sadowskys. Ergonomics are excellent.

Tone: reverse P is significantly different than standard P, but I already have some standard P-basses and I was looking for something different/modern. Reverse P gives more growl to the BEA strings, more depth to the DG -- a more modern tone IMO, I can see why many prefer it. The Music Man pickup has fabulous growl and zing, and series mode gives it more output and punch. Love the Aggie preamp (boost only treble/bass). I also added a passive tone. There's a pickup pan, but as expected, phasing effects happen when two adjacent pickups are blended: the result is an ultra-modern tone that's interesting, but I doubt I'll use it much.

Playability: again, love the satin/nearly-bare finish on the back of the neck! Profile is nearly perfect! Fingerboard radius seems flatter than Sadowsky... not saying that's an improvement, but I love it. Fretwork and intonation are as perfect as I've encountered, even way up the neck on the B string, even when playing chords.

The only negative (a slight one) is that action gets a smidge higher than I like above the 12th fret, but I'm sure that can be corrected easily. Oh... a note on Elfin vs. Elfin Plus: the Plus has Fender-style ergonomics, which means you don't have to reach farther out when playing down near the nut as you do with Spectors and some other 24-fretters! However that also means that you have to reach in over your body to access the highest frets. Also, the heel partially restricts access to those highest frets. No big deal to me, I have never cared about 24 frets, it was not on my mind when I chose this bass, and I can reach the highest frets if I have to. Just mentioning it for those who want easier access way up there -- and if you do, the scaled down Elfin is the one to get.

I know I'm overlooking some stuff but it's late and I need to post pics. Further thoughts later... first gig will be Saturday evening, can't wait!

MKreds-jpg.445078.jpg

Marshall Perry's quick snap of his Dakota Red Plus (front) next to my Pearl

My own cell phone pics, hurriedly taken (had a dinner date):

20140717_182047.png
20140717_182403.jpg



20140717_182413.jpg
20140717_182809.jpg


20140717_184211.png
20140717_184307.jpg


20140717_183810.jpg


Closeup of Luminlays and EVO fretwire. The EVO wire is harder than nickel (not as hard as SS), and has an attractive gold hue throughout (NOT plated)
20140717_183519.jpg
20140717_183558.jpg


Charged Luminlays indoors -- moderately lighted room
20140717_190256.jpg


20140717_222239.jpg


20140717_222148.jpg


Zero fret!
20140717_222343.jpg
 
Last edited:
Misc:

Bass was beautifully packed in the box: lots of bubble wrap both outside and inside the case!

Gig bag is a Protec Contego, new offering for Martin Keith, with which he was impressed -- and so am I. No gig test yet, obviously, but it seems to be in the same ballpark as the Mono M80 and Sadowsky Portabag. Has plenty of pockets, and the outside zippers glide more smoothly than any I've encountered. All zipper handles have rubber sleeves, and on top of that, the case has a velcro flap (near the handle) to cover the outside zipper handles: so, Protec wants to protect your furniture and your car in addition to your bass -- a nice touch!

Luminlay provides a small but intense LED flashlight (with keychain) for charging the glow-in-the-dark side dots. Apparently the dots glow for a half hour. I haven't tested yet, but I'll be happy with the choice even if I have to charge them more frequently (only necessary on dark stages, which I often play). I didn't want the expense of inlaid LED side dots, and while I do like the FretFX stick-on LED strip that I use on two of my basses, the Luminlays are less fragile and more permanent.

I went with D'Addario XL nickel rounds. I haven't used them in a very long time (I'm usually an SS guy), but Martin believes in them, and when I don't have a strong preference I'm happy to defer to the luthier. Turns out I like them a lot. Just as I recalled, the windings are very even, unlike some other brands. Perhaps the seemingly perfect intonation speaks to string quality as well as instrument build quality and setup? It's possible.

Last but definitely not least:
  • The bass sounds amazing when unplugged, and I could feel the tone as well as hear it. I have some other nice basses so this is not a first, but it's always a welcome discovery!
  • I took a few minutes to look for dead spots. None found! I can't say they don't exist, but if they do they're not significant. :)
 
I took a few minutes to look for dead spots. None found! I can't say they don't exist, but if they do they're not significant. :)
Both of mine have dead spots around the 9th fret location on the G string. No biggie, all my other basses have dead spots in one location or another (except for the headless Yamaha I recently sold, it was perfect), it just goes with the territory when using wood products.
 
Both of mine have dead spots around the 9th fret location on the G string. No biggie, all my other basses have dead spots in one location or another (except for the headless Yamaha I recently sold, it was perfect), it just goes with the territory when using wood products.
I agree. Overall, there are weak spots, there are dead spots, and then there are DEAD spots. Heck, the graphite-necked Modulus Quantum I owned wasn't perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5StringPocket
Such a sweet bass, which made me want to get a bass with a maple board. Let me know how you like the reverse P on the gig. Mine's standard P inside, but they're reversible (benefit of the big shells), so I might give reverse a whirl sometime just for fun.

I really love this design...it's just an ultimate rock bass for me. Hearing the two basses at Martin's workspace, I thought our two basses had pretty different "personalities" sonically, but both were stellar.
 
What I like even more than the design, are the pickups being so close together. For my taste, I would have moved them both about half an inch further towards the bridge. That's how I like the sound. But that bass is not mine, therefore the pickups are right in the middle :P

Such a sweet bass, which made me want to get a bass with a maple board. Let me know how you like the reverse P on the gig. Mine's standard P inside, but they're reversible (benefit of the big shells), so I might give reverse a whirl sometime just for fun.

I really love this design...it's just an ultimate rock bass for me. Hearing the two basses at Martin's workspace, I thought our two basses had pretty different "personalities" sonically, but both were stellar.
 
What I like even more than the design, are the pickups being so close together. For my taste, I would have moved them both about half an inch further towards the bridge. That's how I like the sound. But that bass is not mine, therefore the pickups are right in the middle :p

I picked the location to have them as similar to the originals as possible, but I could see it sounding great a little towards the bridge too. The Nordstrand pickups are pretty fat sounding, so there would still be a good bass response I'm guessing. Close together also just looks killer; I don't know why more basses don't have that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas Kievit
Yeah totally. I already have that idea for a long time already.. Why still having those standard pickup positions? I think it would be great if more companies decided to move the original pickup positions a bit more to the bridge.

I picked the location to have them as similar to the originals as possible, but I could see it sounding great a little towards the bridge too. The Nordstrand pickups are pretty fat sounding, so there would still be a good bass response I'm guessing. Close together also just looks killer; I don't know why more basses don't have that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smperry
Yeah, definitely good people.

I get the idea of having the pickups far apart for the range of sounds between the two pickups, but there are great low-midrange sounds with pickups towards the middle. With my earlier fretless I wanted the pickups closer together, but having them touching takes it to another level. My earlier fretted (Myrtle) and later fretless (British Racing Green) ones have traditional jazz positions, so it's cool to have both.
 

Attachments

  • koa elfin plus.jpg
    koa elfin plus.jpg
    54.9 KB · Views: 168
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas Kievit