• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New Precision V ?

I tried one in Miami about a month ago. It felt very good construction wise. The sound was good but to me it didn't have the P-bass sound that I like. It sounded a bit more modern and even though the neck felt great and the rosewood fretboard was stunning it didn't spoke to ME.

It does seem like a very good instrument for someone who has been waiting for a passive 5 string Pbass for a lot of years.

Just my opinion.
 
Well, I think I'm going to have to post a rebuttal video to that review. Someone commented that the B sounds hollow. First of all, consider where the pickup is located under the B string... pretty close to the neck. I would wager that most guys playing 5 strings are using two pickup models, or perhaps one pickup in a bridge position, like a MM. If you take any 2 pickup 5 string and use just the front pickup - particularly if it's a single coil - the tone is definitely what I would call "hollow". It's mostly a product of the pickup placement. The string response on the bass is not the issue, nor is the relative volume.

However, I do think the tone on the video review I posted could have been better. I've recently started recording the audio of my video reviews into Protools instead of using the crappy mic built in to the camera. The P5 was one of the last ones I did that way. I'll try to shoot a short clip of the P5 recorded direct. This bass has a great B string, I liked it so much that I bought it rather than send it back. I've used it on many gigs and continue to love playing it.

I also just reviewed the Am Std. Jazz 5 for the Bass Emporium newsletter, it should be up on their site in a few days, complete with 6 recorded samples. Another winner!
 
Just watched Ed's video, neat bass but I didn't dig the slap tone at all, there are some songs with a slapped P bass that I like but this one simply didn't have it in my opinion, maybe it sounds smoother and not as twangy with the tone knob rolled down a notch?

vinny, knowing Fender, I REALLY doubt they're available as lefties, so, yes, you'd probably have to go Custom Shop.
 
I played one last week at the GC here and really liked it. I found the neck to be just a bit chunkier than I like but I could get used to it.

As for the tones, very traditional P-Bass tones to me...nice slap sound when I rolled the tone knob off a bit - it sounded thick and full.

I just may pull the trigger on one.
 
I bought one and like it. It sounds like a good P. It feels great, looks good and the weight is only 8.8 lbs. The satin finished neck (back) feels so smooth; it's my favorite finish. Personally, I think one of the best slap tones comes from a Jazz, so I didn't expect it to have a great slap tone, but it's not bad. I would roll the treble down for that. In the few jams I have played it, it sounds great paired up with a SansAmp PBDDI. A little drive gives it a nice big furry sound. The B-string is pretty good.
 
I use to want one. But that B string was not good :(

Well, I'll say it again and then shut up. The B string is great on this bass. If it wasn't I wouldn't have bought it. It may not sound great on the demo, but... I didn't buy it because the B string was weak.

Who you gonna trust, trained professional Ed Friedland or a webcam mic? I know I've got one on order.
 
Well, I'll say it again and then shut up. The B string is great on this bass. If it wasn't I wouldn't have bought it. It may not sound great on the demo, but... I didn't buy it because the B string was weak.

I found NOTHING lacking in the B string as well. It was the first concern I had and the concern was immediately put to rest.

You can tell so little about tone from a youtube video... Don't get me wrong Ed, I dig all of your videos and have found them really insightful but I usually like to play a bass before I buy and the new 5 string P-Bass is a definite winner in my book.

Thanks for continuing to enlighten the bass world.

Mark
 

Latest posts