For sure. 1 1/2" vs 1 5/8" or 1 11/16" at the nut is a very noticeable difference for sure. The old spec P width of 1 3/4" seems really wide to me on a 4 strings, however, my 5 stringers are 1 7/8" and it seems 'normal.'This one is 1.465" at the nut. My Squier P is 1.625" and my American Special P is 1.640". On paper, this doesn't seem like much. In my left hand, it's the difference between a baseball bat and a chicken bone.