• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Non dead flats

They last a lot longer than rounds. What i should have written is...: After some time e.g Labellas gets better. Rotos gets worse..imo. More like rounds i guess. Anyways Rotos are great strings. Nothing sounds like em.

Gotcha. I was familiar with the the rounds, but this is really my first real exposure to flats. I'd tried a few, and usually they make it 2 days. I did almost two months with the ECB81 chromes, which are the current record holder. These roto flats with 105 E feel less tense than the 100 chrome - I don't know if that's just subjective experience or inconsistent manufacture, but so far they feel pretty ok and I totally hear you on at least the initial out-of-the-box sound. I've heard from a lot of people that they don't die gracefully, I guess we'll see!

OP, red silk could be the Rotosound flats we're talking about. I haven't seen them in person but it looks like the uber expensive TI Flats could also be a possibility? I don't have any experience but people say they feel floppy - maybe that's what you have?

My friend swears by his Cobalt flats. I may give them a shot next. The installation directions seem weird, but they are supposed to give you a roundwound sound with more of a flatwound feel.
 
If you want roundwound bright, why not just play rounds?

I just found them very easy on my fingers, was suprised at that.

This is a case of the OP wanting to have the cake and eat it, too. The bright sound of rounds with the smooth feel of flats!

Incidentally, that's exactly how Ernie Ball has been marketing the Cobalt Flats - "strings that feel like flats but sound like rounds".
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyM and Gasman
This is a case of the OP wanting to have the cake and eat it, too. The bright sound of rounds with the smooth feel of flats!

Incidentally, that's exactly how Ernie Ball has been marketing the Cobalt Flats - "strings that feel like flats but sound like rounds".
And that's exactly how they sound for the first month or so and then some of the zing goes away and leaves you with a nice balanced sounding flat with nice tension to boot. I have them on my Pbass and they sound great. Have a set for my Rick when I want a change from rounds.
 
This is a case of the OP wanting to have the cake and eat it, too. The bright sound of rounds with the smooth feel of flats!

Incidentally, that's exactly how Ernie Ball has been marketing the Cobalt Flats - "strings that feel like flats but sound like rounds".

I agree with the Cobalts. They are the brightest flats I've ever tried, brighter than D'adario or TI (which, to the OP, I bet are on your bass, or maybe rotosounds).

Back to the Cobalts, they are worth a try. Personally, I found them too bright on my Stingray, but I bet they would sound awesome on a P or jazz.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bassbully
This is a case of the OP wanting to have the cake and eat it, too. The bright sound of rounds with the smooth feel of flats!

Incidentally, that's exactly how Ernie Ball has been marketing the Cobalt Flats - "strings that feel like flats but sound like rounds".
Well I guess he better get used to changing expensive strings a lot more often.
 
Man, this thread has some life to it. Never knew flats versus rounds was such an existential question. To be honest, never even knew of flatwounds until my 30's.
Kids...

:D

Believe it or not, it wasn't up until the mid-to-late 70's that most manufacturers shipped basses with rounds. And I don't think Fender did it till like 79.
 
Tried a set of flats today for the first time. Very easy on the fingers but dead as all heck. Nothing to them besides a muddy thump. Are there any that keep some of the brightness of rounds?


GET THE FLATS THAT HAVE RIDGES

b%20420.jpg