• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Nordstrand Big Singles... I'm not digging the tone

Thanks for all of the responses, I'm not going to give up on these pickups just yet. Jazz single coils are my favorite tone and I'm sure there's something out of the ordinary going on here with my setup. I like the idea of pulling out the preamp and running this setup passive. It's about the only thing I haven't tried. It will take me at least two weeks before I get the time to do this, but I'll report back with my findings.
Everyone's experience is different, but mine was that I pulled a Sadowsky pre out of my jazz bass after it had been in there since 2008. I like Sadowsky preamps - my ears tell me they lend a caffeinated vibe to a bass' tone. But this bass was already high strung and the Sad was a bridge too far in the tonal direction the bass was already pointing.

I dropped in a nice Emerson VVT pack with an oil and paper capacitor and the bass sounds really nice. Maybe a bit more vintage, but to my point above I could always get the Sadowsky tone back by way of one of their pedal preamps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpeakerBoxxx
The EQ centers for the ODP3 are not the greatest. Too low and too high. Had one for a few years and was eventually glad to be rid of it.

I suggest Audere, John East etc. Or one of the recent filter preamps Lustihand and others ( look into those).

Regarding the Big Singles, I preferred the Big Blade Warm&Wooly after comparing both for a period.

Good luck

Yep, completely agree. A friend of mine upgraded an MIA Fender active Jazz IV with those Big Blades and just for the fun of knowledge we put my John East J-Tone 01 in it, some solder modifications of course as the jack connector is not located at the same place. He bought a John East preamp after the first rehearsal he played with it, he found it was the perfect match, way better than the stock Fender active preamp.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jett Litt
I'm also not at all a fan of the OBP3 which is surprising because of all the reviews I read about it led me to believe it would be a perfect fit for me. It sounded lifeless with no aggression whatsoever. I like an aggressive sound and that preamp just sucked in my bass. Replaced with a Bart NTMB and my bass sounds much better.

Not particularly helpful to OP, but this is so interesting to me. I have Big Splits and an OBP3 in one of my basses and it's the most aggressive-sounding bass I own, including a Dingwall. In contrast I've always found the NTMB to be very sterile and polite.

Just shows how subjective these terms are, and how many other factors there are in the tone of an instrument.
 
Hi Everyone,
Sonia here from Nordstrand. If you are having issues getting through to customer service, feel free to DM me here on Talk Bass. Or tag me in the comments. Or email me directly. [email protected]. Things have really amped up around here and with all of the snow this past season we lost some of our customer service for a bit and we are constantly trying to catch up. If you hang out on the Acinonyx TB page you will see I am pretty active there.

Just like any product, our pups are subject to different tastes, tone is dependent on wood type, strings, position, rig and the hands that are playing it etc. Some people love the tone of our pickups, (we have so many variations, its hard to believe any one couldn't find something they like!) but some like barts tone or EMG etc. You would be surprised how many people call us saying they love another manufacturers pup, and do we have anything like that? Please, go buy the pups you like! We are not here to force our pups on anyone if they have a different preference. We will lead you in the best direction even if it is another manufacturer. There is a lot of chatter here about different things. If you still have a questions, send me a message.
 
Not particularly helpful to OP, but this is so interesting to me. I have Big Splits and an OBP3 in one of my basses and it's the most aggressive-sounding bass I own, including a Dingwall. In contrast I've always found the NTMB to be very sterile and polite.

Just shows how subjective these terms are, and how many other factors there are in the tone of an instrument.
True, not particularly helpful to OP. Just felt strongly about the lack of aggression in the OBP3. I have EMG 40DCX with their BQC preamp and that is also pretty polite compared to my Lane Poor MM and Bart NTMB pre. The Lane Poor originally had the OBP3 paired with it and that completely lacked aggression. Just my strange 2 cents. I think that preamp and pickup combinations can sometimes give unexpected results. Definitely can be an expensive rabbit hole to go down.
 
I'm more leaning to the pre-amp as the issue.
I've owned lots of Nordstrand pickups in my 17 years of playing.
While I prefer the Big Splits over the Big Singles, I've never played a Big X equipped bass that I didn't like the tone of.
But that's me.
we all have a "great tone" in our heads, and it's always a fun chase.
Those warm/wooly blades are also fantastic jazz-style pickups, and they can fit into the standard jazz-pickup form factor.
 
Since you're in SoCal, you could just go to there shop in San Bernadino for a surprise visit :D

Lately there calls and emails have been on the decline. I've had people I know try calling but no answer, till they went on here and made a thread about having been sent the wrong pickups they ordered to which one of the workers at Nordstrand responded :rolleyes:

I have no beef with Nordstrand, I love there pickups and preamps. Just wish they can do better with communication like they were before.

I'm sure the system works well enough to place an order to buy another set of pickups. Service after the sale is getting worse all the time-by many companies.
 
Your big singles are basically fat vintage jazz pickups in an "easier to route" bigger shell. So you either like like that tone or you dont. String choice is often critical when pairing with a specific pickup type. You could try a string change and a passive tone / blender / volume option to see if it's the basic tone that you are looking for.

The great news with Nordstand pickups is that their larger shells make pickup swap outs a breeze and you can easily drop in another pickup (P bass, Humbucker etc) without expensive and messy re-routing.

The only issue you may find with the Norstrand portfolio of pickups is that they cater for the modern looking, but retro sounding pickups. They all use Alnico magnets. If you want something brighter, then Barolini might be the way to go....thankfully Nordys use the same Bartolini humbucker shell sizes! So drop ins are a comparitive breeze.

That seems like strange advice. I don't think you will find many people saying Barotolinis are brighter than Nordys.

I have 2 basses with big singles, love them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoniaMara
I carefully build, and measure every aspect of a design, before I start a bass project. I know where I prefer my pickup locations. I have several builds, dating back to the early 80's. My Avatar pic, is my 1994 maple bass with 3 Alembic WMXY pickups and the Stanley Clarke tone circuit. The bass sounds amazing, and it should, with what that circuit cost- even at my then dealer cost. I don't think I could duplicate it now- even if the combinations were available, it would cost around 3K for the circuit. Really. I have a similar instrument with EMG's and it. too- has a killer tone, but slightly different.. it's also maple, with the neck and bridge pickups in almost exactly the same location. My last build of that shape and pickup location positions, is two piece Alder with a two piece flamed maple top half. Both pieces are the same thickness, it's not a top and back. I decided to make an 'art' piece, as well as keeping with my design elements. I opted for a now rare bare aluminum set of Lace Alumitones, passive just volume, blend and tone. Aluminum Hipshot bridge, and satin Sperzels, it came out just as I planned.
No matter what I did, I just could not get into them. I listened intently, to both the bass into my headphones, and on live recordings. It sounded great in the mix, but I really did not like the tone of the pickups- they have EVERY frequency in the spectrum, going on, all the time. That, is actually amazing. If you want cut, and grind- man, there's really not many pickups that have that quality, passive. They have a 'harshness' in the mid, that could not be EQ'ed out, after I installed a preamp. But I'm old school- used to conventional wound pickups. I swapped the Alumitones for EMG's, and the full BQC circuit.
A noticeable improvement, but there is something about the mids coming from THIS particular bass, that the EMG's did not change.
I decided to try passive set of Bartolinis. I installed the BD5CBC dual coils, with a three position mini switch for each one, and an Audere preamp. The bass has a significantly different, and better tone now, than it has ever had. The SWITCHING, is a big part of this - the options make this bass one I'll take to gigs, as opposed to trying to think if it'll work for the music I'm going to play. There is still a mid harshness, and I think it's really just the sound of this particular combination of woods and the stainless frets. What is a bit inconvenient- is that we never know what even the best pickups, and preamps are going to sound like- until they're installed in our basses. That, can get costly.
 

Attachments

  • 20200127_161105.jpg
    20200127_161105.jpg
    562 KB · Views: 39
True, not particularly helpful to OP. Just felt strongly about the lack of aggression in the OBP3. I have EMG 40DCX with their BQC preamp and that is also pretty polite compared to my Lane Poor MM and Bart NTMB pre. The Lane Poor originally had the OBP3 paired with it and that completely lacked aggression. Just my strange 2 cents. I think that preamp and pickup combinations can sometimes give unexpected results. Definitely can be an expensive rabbit hole to go down.
oh, sorry, I was saying my comment wasn't helpful to the OP. Yours was far more relevant. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JuanB
Yeah, warm is the direction I'd like to move closer towards. I've read good things about the Big Blades, but I'm a little put off by Nordstrand at the moment. I tried to contact them a couple of times over the past year and not once did they ever respond.
Also, I was wondering if Nordstrand pickups have some inherent tone that is present across their whole line. Kinda like how some artists have their own style and you can tell that any one piece is theirs just by looking at it.
My experience with Nordstrand has been very positive. I have three different style pickups on different basses and love them all. I have Big Splits on two custom basses, an MM5.2 on another custom built and CND P/J on my Ibanez SR655. All sound great and all record very well. I have good had communication with them for advice. It wasn't immediate but it was helpful. I'm a big fan.
 
Yeah, warm is the direction I'd like to move closer towards. I've read good things about the Big Blades, but I'm a little put off by Nordstrand at the moment. I tried to contact them a couple of times over the past year and not once did they ever respond.
Also, I was wondering if Nordstrand pickups have some inherent tone that is present across their whole line. Kinda like how some artists have their own style and you can tell that any one piece is theirs just by looking at it.

I reached out to Nordstrand in regards to custom pickup covers and they responded in a way that made it feel like they were agitated with me. Lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpeakerBoxxx
That seems like strange advice. I don't think you will find many people saying Barotolinis are brighter than Nordys.

I have 2 basses with big singles, love them.

Over the years, I've built lots of different basses. Two of which, I specked with Nordys in them and two basses with Barts. I like them all, I'm not dissing one brand over the other. Bart's sound different to Nordys because they use different magnets in their construction.
I like the Big Singles a lot, but I also like Bart Jazz PU's too. They sound very different. It depends on what one is looking for…which I think was the original question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoniaMara