I agree on the lacking character comments. I've had the bass for 6 years and it was fine with flats for Motown stuff. I recently installed Aguilar 4P60 which are nice warm polite pickups. On my other P I am currently trying out the P46 pickups but have some used CS62s coming. I was and might still, try the NP4Vs based on the FatBassTones demo if I am not very happy with the CS62s.
I remember liking the Custom Shop 62. By memory the Nordstrand sounded like a vintage P-bass, but I perceived it as a bit laid back. I just pushed the amp a little more and the NP4V gained a bit more punch. I haven't played with the Nordstrand for quite some time so I'm not completely sure of the details. Either way I liked the Nordy pickups. The CS62's, though, were more my speed. I'll be interested in reading about where you land and why.
Cheers
