So, it has been a few weeks since I received my Vintage Four and I have been playing it A LOT.
This is one of those basses that you can pick up and play and it just disappears, leaving only the music. It feels like an old, broken in pair of Doc Martens. The bass balances beautifully and it feels light on the strap. The neck has just the right amount of girth for my long fingers and large hands, neither feeling like a baseball bat nor a pencil. Just right. It is finished smoothly and the fret and nut dressings are as good as I've ever seen. (All of my Ltd's have immaculate fretwork too.)
The tone, while subjective, is everything I look for in a good P-Bass and the addition of the J pickup opens up the possibilities immensely. Having never really been a Jazz Bass guy, I don't know that I am a good judge of what a bridge position J "should" sound like, but this one is definitely usable. I expected the soloed J to be thin and noisy but it retains a lot of low end while adding a snap to a note's attack. Nice!
Both pickups and Tone full up is where it's at for me, though. The pickups balance so nicely that I can get a huge range of tones from changing my hand position or plucking technique, allowing me to get a wide range of tones without touching the knobs.
The only downsides to me are little things: I could do without the relic treatment and I'm not really wild about the sunburst/tort combo. The control layout has to go, too. I will swap the pick guard out for a 3-ply B-W-B and I ordered the pots to rewire it to V B T instead of the stock, V V T scheme it has now. Easy and inexpensive "fixes" for things that aren't really a big problem to begin with. The dual volume controls are helpful for blending the pickups for sure, but all of my other basses and guitars have a single volume. That being the case, I have gotten used to doing volume swells and tremolo effects using the volume control and this layout doesn't really work for that.
All in all though, I am definitely satisfied with the Vintage Four. It is a fine companion to the ESP/LTD Surveyor '87 I bought earlier this year and between them, I can't imagine needing anything from a passive bass that these two can't handle.